PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Scottish Control (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/351812-scottish-control.html)

daynehold 20th November 2008 18:13

Scottish Control
 
Sorry to show my ignorance (question probably posed previously) but does anyone know when the move to the new ATCC is scheduled to take place. I understand that the sub centre currently located at Manchester is due to be incorporated into the new facility - will the call sign still be "Manchester Control" or will pilots be calling Scotish as they climb out south over Cheshire?

BigDaddyBoxMeal 21st November 2008 12:33

I wouldn't think the R/T callsign will be affected by the geographical location of the unit, otherwise there would be a "Swanwick Director" for EGLL, or maybe even a "Starbucks Control" !! :)

BDiONU 21st November 2008 19:02

There will be a phased transition, the dates currently being worked to (not set in stone except MACC) are the military going live in November 2009, ScACC in December and MACC in January 2010.
The callsign of Prestwick Centre is under discussion and will be subject to approval by DAP.

BD

Dee Mac 22nd November 2008 10:00

No discussion, the New Scottish Centre will have two callsigns. Those sectors currently run by Manchester will have the callsign "Manchester Control", the sectors currently run by Scottish will have the callsign "Scottish Control". Nobody is going to alter that, I'm not using a different callsign to placate the Manch controllers, and the Manch guys aren't stupid such that using some generic w*nky callsign is going to make the move any easier.

And that's from the horses mouth, not it's arse.

PS VOTE NO

BDiONU 22nd November 2008 13:26


Originally Posted by Dee Mac (Post 4547265)
No discussion, the New Scottish Centre will have two callsigns. Those sectors currently run by Manchester will have the callsign "Manchester Control", the sectors currently run by Scottish will have the callsign "Scottish Control". Nobody is going to alter that,

:rolleyes: Prestwick Centre will have a single callsign, mandated by law.

BD

Lurking123 22nd November 2008 13:31


.... the military going live in November 2009...
Is that the new, abridged version of the military? ;)

BDiONU 22nd November 2008 13:35


Originally Posted by Lurking123 (Post 4547652)
Is that the new, abridged version of the military? ;)

Unless MoD change their minds again ;)

BD

Lurking123 22nd November 2008 16:17

I was led to believe it was NATS, this time. Maybe they should just leave everything as it is. :ok:

Spitoon 22nd November 2008 17:37


Prestwick Centre will have a single callsign, mandated by law.
Which law would that be?

throw a dyce 22nd November 2008 18:50

Anglia Radar,done from Aberdeen has the callsign Anglia Radar.All other sectors done from Aberdeen have separate callsigns.Haven't heard of this law either.

wiccan 22nd November 2008 19:14

"Manchester Radar" in a Scots accent is going to sound fantastic.....

Take up the Hold 22nd November 2008 19:17

There will be only one callsign at PC. What it will be I don't know but, once cross training starts you cannot have one quarter of the Ops Room (layout not size) calling themselves something different.

TUTH

Spitoon 22nd November 2008 19:18

But maybe better than a Mancunian accent?

But I guess it's hard to tell - last time I saw Manch there weren't many Mancunians there!

landedoutagain 22nd November 2008 19:29

manchester radar will still be in manchester tho! :ok:

Doncaster radar is (was?) done from liverpool!

ZOOKER 22nd November 2008 19:34

"Which law would that be"?

The law according to BDiONU, which is often total horsesh1t, as frequent readers of these fora will already be aware.

STANSTED RADAR, - at Swanwick.
GATWICK RADAR, - at Swanwick.
LUTON RADAR, - at Swanwick.
HEATHROW DIRECTOR, - at Swanwick.
LONDON CONTROL, at, wait for it....Swanwick.
THAMES RADAR, - at Tower Bridge?.....Nope! - Swanwick, (Yawn).
LIVERPOOL RADAR, AND, DONCASTER RADAR - at John Lennon. (No, I don't understand that either)!
:}:}:}
TUTH - "You cannot have one quarter of the ops room calling themselves something different". Oh yes you can! :E

ZOOKER 22nd November 2008 19:52

Not forgetting:-
PENNINE RADAR.
and of course, LIVERPOOL RADAR, both of which, I believe, once shared the same ops room as MANCHESTER CONTROL.

Lurking123 22nd November 2008 20:04

Sorry to pee on your corn flakes chaps, but there is something written in one of those mindless ICAO docs that tries to standardise ATCC callsigns. I'm not convinced it is enshrined in UK law but, assuming the UK hasn't filed a difference, I guess there will be a common name. Certainly the mil adopted "London Mil" when Swanwick/LATCC(Mil) merged.

Pennine Radar, what's that? I thought you lot off-loaded that particular task to LATCC(Mil) a few years back.

BDiONU 22nd November 2008 20:08


Originally Posted by Spitoon (Post 4547988)
Which law would that be?

NATS apply to the Directorate of Airspace Policy for a unit callsign and DAP decides on what the unit callsign may be. ATSSD licences the unit to provide an ATC service using the callsign which they're authorised to use. The law to which I'm refering is the licence.

BD

BDiONU 22nd November 2008 20:35


Originally Posted by throw a dyce (Post 4548081)
Anglia Radar,done from Aberdeen has the callsign Anglia Radar.All other sectors done from Aberdeen have separate callsigns.Haven't heard of this law either.

Each of those unit tasks has a separate licence. Prestwick Centre will have a single licence for the unit.

BD

landedoutagain 22nd November 2008 20:38

well, if its based on what the licence says, I hope that the guys at manch get a big payrise if they have to change their licences to scottish control. After all, scotland is much bigger than manchester....! :}

ZOOKER 22nd November 2008 20:43

"Prestwick Centre will have a single licence for the unit".
What, including the 'Oceanic' bit, called Shanwick? :E

fisbangwollop 22nd November 2008 21:07

A competition will be run shortly in the company glossy mag, "Airway" or whetever they call it now to come up with a new callsign.....the winning vote will recieve an all expenses trip to Wonderwest world Ayr , or is it called Craig Tara now?.....the runner up will recieve 2 weeks in the Bahamas in the company of Mr Barron!!....

My vote is for Redbrae Contol.:ok:

Foondoot 22nd November 2008 21:47


The callsign of Prestwick Centre is under discussion and will be subject to approval by DAP.
Is there not a different and unassociated unit that already uses that prefix? What a strange idea.

Spitoon 22nd November 2008 21:59


Originally Posted by BDiONU
NATS apply to the Directorate of Airspace Policy for a unit callsign and DAP decides on what the unit callsign may be. ATSSD licences the unit to provide an ATC service using the callsign which they're authorised to use. The law to which I'm refering is the licence.

Ahhh, let's look at this, bit by bit. I always thought that and applicant wishing to establish an Aeronautical Ground Station proposed the callsign to be used. The CAA/DAP assesses whether it is appropriate and in accordance with ICAO SARPs and, if it is, will accept the use of that callsign in association with the radio station. As I understand it, CAA/DAP does not simply decide what the station callsign will be. This process seems to be consistent with the text on the relevant application form - Form SRG 1417.

When you say that CAA/SRG/ATSD licences the unit to provide a service are you talking about the approval to provide an air traffic service issued under the provisions of Article 100 of the ANO? Or perhaps you mean the approval to operate the equipment issued under the provisions of Article 124 of the ANO? Or maybe even the radio station licence which is not issued by the CAA but rather by Ofcom? None of which really are 'law' - I suspect what you mean is that the station operator must comply with the conditions of the licence or approval related to the operation of the equipment.

I have to say that I have personally seen dozens of ATC units which use a number of different callsigns, all from the same facility too. They're called aerodromes. Why, I've even sat next to another controller, as close as I am to this computer, and used a different callsign to my colleague - don't push me too much on the details but I think my callsign ended with 'Ground' and my colleague's with 'Tower'. My, when I think back, those were confusing days - having to remember which callsign to useand when. Mind you, I guess it must be OK because one of those mindless ICAO docs to which Lurking, one of your colleague I would have to guess, refers seems to be written in such a way as to mean that callsigns reflect the unit or service being provided. It's Annex 10 Vol 2 para 5.2.1.7.1 if you want to look it up.

So, I'm afraid I'm still a bit puzzled by this law you mentioned.....

joe99 23rd November 2008 00:12

New Shanwick Control (or shanwick)
 
As it looks like Oceanic will be the inaugural users of npc/pc/new prestwick/npwick/new shanwick shouldn't we just stick with that. After all, whats in a name?:D

Foondoot 23rd November 2008 00:36

What was wrong with McNERC?

BDiONU 23rd November 2008 06:23

Spitoon Your post encapsulates what I was trying to say in my clumsy way "what you mean is that the station operator must comply with the conditions of the licence or approval related to the operation of the equipment."
DAP don't allocate the callsign but can refuse to allow the use of a proposal, as in the case of TC moving South from WD.

BD

Lurking123 23rd November 2008 06:34

Did DAP get involved in the Swanwick Watch re-brandings then, or was that just an internal willy wave? :)

landedoutagain 23rd November 2008 10:36

have heard a rumour that the NPC 'super' watches will not be colours like swanwick, but names based on tartans.... :}

Track Jitter 23rd November 2008 10:45

The Ocean and the Mil will go across at the same time, Nov 09. That is the latest plan, no doubt subject to change!

eastern wiseguy 23rd November 2008 14:37


but names based on tartans

What...Black watch then....




hat coat sporran.......

ZOOKER 23rd November 2008 17:27

landedout,
Apparently, they will not be called watches. To facilitate the integration of the folk from Manchester, the watches will become 'Clans'. :}:}:}

Lurking123 23rd November 2008 18:49

Will there be language training?

Vote NO 23rd November 2008 19:29

Apparently no one is going to Scottish from Manch, so it will still be called Scottish :}

ZOOKER 23rd November 2008 20:36

Lurking,
Almost certainly. Key elements of the foundation course will include:-

See you (Jimmy).
The correct pronunciation of Spidean a'Choire Leith. :uhoh:
The Noo.
"And are there not two G's in Bugger Off"?
Will ye no come back again?
HOOTS MON, There's a moose, loose, aboot this hoose. (Apologies to Lord Rockingham's XI).
"Afore ye go" :ok:
The ICAO definition of a Tappet Hen.
Correct usage of the words Corstorphine and Cowcaddens.
HOOTS MON, there's juice, loose, aboot this hoose. (Apologies to Maynard's Wine Gums).
A short essay question on Tannochbrae.
And of course, the exact meaning of the often heard phraseology:-
"Robbie, there's been another murrrrder". :E

throw a dyce 23rd November 2008 21:30

Lurking,
I think you need to look at this...Parliamo Scots?

Vote NO 24th November 2008 08:45

Essential reading for any potential immigrant from Manchester to Scotland

Great Scottish Inventions, which include The Bank Of England and radar :E

SCOTLAND'S INVENTIONS

And

Scotland was a completely separated land mass from England in the days of Pangaea. They collided millions of years ago, and stuck together ever since, but their geological composition is totally different :eek:

Jumbo Driver 24th November 2008 09:24

Callsign for PC
 
How about "Preston Airways" ...


JD
;)

Vote NO 24th November 2008 12:06

Those were the days!!!:ok:

chiglet 24th November 2008 17:26

How's aboot...PATCRU...Prestwick Air Traffic Control Radar Unit...:ok:


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:11.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.