PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Latest VHF com piss-offs! (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/507536-latest-vhf-com-piss-offs.html)

PhiltheReaper 12th Feb 2013 22:18

I may be out of my depth here, but I must sat I disagree with the vast majority on this issue of "fully ready" and indeed slightly on the issue of being ready on reaching. I'm not disputing the instructions for proper RT, merely the argument about the use of English.

ZOOKER, rightly said in my opinion that context is key to a ready message. Is the "ready on reaching" not that context? As a paraphrase of "ready to depart, on reaching HP" ? Perhaps I am wrong.

Most importantly though, readiness is not a bi-polar state I believe. It is possible to be in a partial state of readiness. This could be why the military use a scale for readiness for example. Allow me to submit an example.

(As with many terrible stories, I have chosen to set the scene with a camping expedition - A gory end to many a fictional hero!)

You are out camping, and your friend says "we have to go in 5 minutes". You know it will take you 10 minutes to pack your things away.

However, after 8 minutes, a group of axe murderers runs towards you in a murderous rage. I believe, that whilst you are 2 minutes from being "fully ready" you will find yourselves very much ready enough to take some departing action, without any delay at all!

An unlikely story, to be sure. But the point stands I hope.

Phil

ZOOKER 12th Feb 2013 22:56

Phil,
many thanks for all the kind comments. Keep reaping, I'm sure it will pay off in the end.
It's a 'Hard Road', as Mr. Mayall said.
Worth it in the end, even if you finish up on EGLLZT.

Minesthechevy 13th Feb 2013 04:47

Totally off-topic, for which I apologise to the sensitive

Zooker - I went to see John Mayall play in Lyon a few months ago - still just as good as he always was...... well worth catching him on tour.

Nautilus Blue 15th Feb 2013 04:31

QFA10 Syndrome (also affects Speedbird).

"Qantas Ten, climb to flight level 390"

"Qantas One Zero, flight level 390"

Ok, I can take a hint,

"Qantas One Zero, contact centre on 123.45"

"Qantas Ten roger, 123.45"

:ugh:

Still, if thats the worst that happens on a shift its been a good day.


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:49.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.