PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   3rd Runway..is there airspace ? (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/493917-3rd-runway-there-airspace.html)

Bagso 26th Aug 2012 12:28

3rd Runway..is there airspace ?
 
Can anybody confirm how capacity constrained the London TMA is ?

Various reports I have read sugest a 3rd runway at LHR would make little difference in terms of increasing capacity as the airspace is so full.

Whats the view of ATC personnel ?

Also appreciate it will never happen but would it not be better to close LGW. LCY LTN STN etc and just build 6 runways at LHR ? Surely this would be easier to control than having such a cockeyed system where everything is crossing in mid air ?

Buster the Bear 26th Aug 2012 13:32

Lots of work going on in the background to increase the airspace capacity in and around London. There was a plan a couple of years back which went out to consultation, but I understand although these plans were delayed, their implementation will occur in the future?

Dan Dare 26th Aug 2012 19:23

Bring back "Tunnels In The Sky" anyone?

whitelighter 26th Aug 2012 19:36

Ahahahahahahahaha,

They can't get planning for the third runway - where the hell do you plan to put 4,5 and 6???

On the beach 26th Aug 2012 20:56

Consultation = Inability to make a decision or "pussy-footing" as Boris would say. :E

AdamFrisch 26th Aug 2012 21:09

LAX runs 4 parallel rwy's in a class B (to the ground) airspace much smaller than London's TMA, so any airspace problem is purely in the minds of legislators and/or ATC. Not only that, ATC at LAX have to contend with GA traffic in the very same airspace (which is not the case in London), but right next to it and even right above the rwy's (the VFR Mini Route) - also not the case in London. My approaches into Hawthorne are side-by-side with big iron 747's on final to 25L - nobody breaks a sweat. And the missed approach on 25L (left turn) takes the big iron right into class D and eventually into uncontrolled airspace, something you'd never see in a million years in Europe.

Talkdownman 26th Aug 2012 21:16


Originally Posted by Dan Dare
Bring back "Tunnels In The Sky" anyone?

Then add a couple of big CBs...

ZOOKER 26th Aug 2012 21:36

6 Runways?

IS THAT ALL ?

Didn't it have 12 at one stage?

ZOOKER 26th Aug 2012 21:40

Talkdownman,
loving your work. ATCO 1 friend of mine was on the CCF simulation and said exactly that. Went very quiet.
Never mind eh?
EFD will sort it out. :E

chevvron 27th Aug 2012 02:38

Tunnels in the Sky = The Beeker Plan = Dave Beech and ? who was the other guy? (had a gammy leg) Liked him, hated Dave.

HEATHROW DIRECTOR 27th Aug 2012 07:15

<<And the missed approach on 25L (left turn) takes the big iron right into class D and eventually into uncontrolled airspace, something you'd never see in a million years in Europe.>>

Thank God for that.

Talkdownman 27th Aug 2012 07:30


Tunnels in the Sky = The Beeker Plan = Dave Beech and ? who was the other guy?
Alan Parker.
'It'll never work'. They were told that by many from Day 1. Huge waste of money. Next please...

MONT BLANC 27th Aug 2012 07:45

Beeker Plan
 
Chevron,

I recollect - through the mists of time - two other people were involved in the 'Beeker Plan in the early days.

One was John Pemberton (gammy leg) I think, but also a really nice chap - John S****** - cannot recall his surname, only that the first letter began with an 'S'.

John Pemberton was an ATCO I, and the section in CAA House was - IMRC - CAP8, so John P was the head of section perhaps. I do remember meeting with them in their office in CAA House - or was it Spacehouse in those days.

I also recollect that Dave Beech and John S went off to the US, and did some work looking at Jacksonville, which they used as the model for CCF.

The simulations were tremendous fun.

My one abiding memory of Dave Beech was being trained by him me as an ASC (Assistant Sector Controller) on SFD/WOR wings: he writing levels on the paper strips with a fountain pen. Takes all sorts.

John Pemberton died a couple of years ago.

MB

MONT BLANC 27th Aug 2012 07:55

Thanks Talkdownman :D

Alan Parker - the other half of Beeker. Alan was a very nice chap.

MB

Bagso 27th Aug 2012 08:11

No GA in the London Airspace....!

My God what planet are you on ?

Northolt, Biggin, Blackbushe, Farnborough......Or did I imagine them.

Anyway back in the real world is there enough room OR NOT, does anybody have a sensible answer ?

obwan 27th Aug 2012 08:41

Alan Parker, didn't he have a band? Or am I thinking of Alan Parsons? One for Zooker I feel.

Brian 48nav 27th Aug 2012 09:06

MONT BLANC
 
John S***** - could that have been John Smeath?

Really nice man, ex RAF Canberra pilot, LL/LHR ATC,LATCC N Bank, sadly died of a heart attack in 1988 (IIRC- 'Window Job' will know), aged only 52 or 53.

BW

MONT BLANC 27th Aug 2012 10:12

John Smeath
 
Spot on Brian. Wasn't he on your watch as well?

A wise chap who was thoroughly decent.

MB

AdamFrisch 27th Aug 2012 10:28

I should have said London Class A. No VFR within miles unless it's the odd SVFR. So yes, if legislators thinks it's "too crowded" and unmanageable and oh so close to max capacity, maybe they should have a little look around how the rest of the world conducts mixed air traffic into a much smaller airspace.

HEATHROW DIRECTOR 27th Aug 2012 12:29

<<No VFR within miles unless it's the odd SVFR.>>

You plainly have knowledge of the London Area. There is LOTS of VFR traffic within a few miles of Heathrow.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:34.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.