Weather avoidance in CAS
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2000
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Weather avoidance in CAS
Hi Ladies and Gents,
I've done a PPRUNE search on this but nothing definitive, so here goes;
Can Pilots flying in CAS avoid weather without asking for ATC permission? I had a discussion the other day with my fellow pilot, who said you don't need ATC's permission, just do it and tell them. I have a feeling he's right but didn't think it was a good idea in a busy, controlled environment.
Your thoughts, legalities etc please.
kind regards
CD
I've done a PPRUNE search on this but nothing definitive, so here goes;
Can Pilots flying in CAS avoid weather without asking for ATC permission? I had a discussion the other day with my fellow pilot, who said you don't need ATC's permission, just do it and tell them. I have a feeling he's right but didn't think it was a good idea in a busy, controlled environment.
Your thoughts, legalities etc please.
kind regards
CD
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: London, UK
Posts: 437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Sunny Warwickshire
Posts: 438
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This thimg has been hammered out on here several times, my theory is this:
If the commander of an aircraft believes that the safety of that aircraft will be compromised by flying through some weather, then he/she has a legal responsibility to avoid that weather.
In a busy TMA environment, it's not always possible to get in on the RT, so then squawk 7700, that way we as ATCO's know that something is not quite right!!
At the endo of the day, the 1261 for a loss of separation is a whole lot less tha losing an aircraft!!
My thoughts, if you need to avoid weather, then avoid it, TELL US WHEN YOU CAN, if you CAN"T, SQUAWK 7700, you'll soon get our attention!!
If the commander of an aircraft believes that the safety of that aircraft will be compromised by flying through some weather, then he/she has a legal responsibility to avoid that weather.
In a busy TMA environment, it's not always possible to get in on the RT, so then squawk 7700, that way we as ATCO's know that something is not quite right!!
At the endo of the day, the 1261 for a loss of separation is a whole lot less tha losing an aircraft!!
My thoughts, if you need to avoid weather, then avoid it, TELL US WHEN YOU CAN, if you CAN"T, SQUAWK 7700, you'll soon get our attention!!
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Fort Worth ARTCC ZFW
Posts: 1,155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Like has been said, if it is for the safety of flight and you can't talk to ATC then do what you have to do, however, to deviate from an ATC clearance, you do need to get approval unless you are invoking your command authority. The command authority however won't relieve you from an investigation if one is warranted.
I have had many aircrew feel that they should be able to deviate anytime that they ask for it. They don't seem to understand that we can only approve the deviation as long as we have no traffic that will be in their way as well as we are not going to violate someone elses airspace prior to getting thier approval. Quite often too, to just go around some bumps and not real large convective activity...
regards
I have had many aircrew feel that they should be able to deviate anytime that they ask for it. They don't seem to understand that we can only approve the deviation as long as we have no traffic that will be in their way as well as we are not going to violate someone elses airspace prior to getting thier approval. Quite often too, to just go around some bumps and not real large convective activity...
regards
