Muppetry at Manch!!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Cork....like.
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Muppetry at Manch!!
From an aircrew perspective......
Got a digital ATIS printout inbound to MAN recently, it said
ARRIVAL RWY 23R.......
and after the weather report(irrelevant to this post)
RWY 23R ILS DME IS U/S...
Then, having set up our approach, (obviously not the ILS), we hear preceeding traffic being cleared an ILS approach.
Now, I hear you say, was'nt your digital ATIS out of date?
Nope, it was issued at 1320z, and printed at 1321z.
So, a rather rushed re-brief.
Two points.
1. Get your terminology right. The ILS was not unserviceable.The DME part of the ILS was u/s. (But at MAN, in fairness, Dme distances from the VOR are on the approach chart, thus satisfying the altitude cross-check)
2. What use is digital ATIS if it does'nt give you the approach type in use - the runway in use does not suffice for FMS equipped A/C - they require some time to programme the new approach.
These ambiguities were unnecessary.
Got a digital ATIS printout inbound to MAN recently, it said
ARRIVAL RWY 23R.......
and after the weather report(irrelevant to this post)
RWY 23R ILS DME IS U/S...
Then, having set up our approach, (obviously not the ILS), we hear preceeding traffic being cleared an ILS approach.
Now, I hear you say, was'nt your digital ATIS out of date?
Nope, it was issued at 1320z, and printed at 1321z.
So, a rather rushed re-brief.
Two points.
1. Get your terminology right. The ILS was not unserviceable.The DME part of the ILS was u/s. (But at MAN, in fairness, Dme distances from the VOR are on the approach chart, thus satisfying the altitude cross-check)
2. What use is digital ATIS if it does'nt give you the approach type in use - the runway in use does not suffice for FMS equipped A/C - they require some time to programme the new approach.
These ambiguities were unnecessary.
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: Wilmslow and North Yorks
Age: 53
Posts: 402
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Seems like a small slip by whoever looks after the ATIS rather than full blown muppetry...
I take it you mentioned it to the ground controller while taxiing in? Or clarified it with the Approach controller?
How do you cope with places like Schipol and their short notice runway changes...if reprogramming the FMS is such as chore?
I take it you mentioned it to the ground controller while taxiing in? Or clarified it with the Approach controller?
How do you cope with places like Schipol and their short notice runway changes...if reprogramming the FMS is such as chore?
Guest
Posts: n/a
RWY 23R ILS DME IS U/S...
Two points.
1. Get your terminology right. The ILS was not unserviceable.The DME part of the ILS was u/s. (But at MAN, in fairness, Dme distances from the VOR are on the approach chart, thus satisfying the altitude cross-check)
Two points.
1. Get your terminology right. The ILS was not unserviceable.The DME part of the ILS was u/s. (But at MAN, in fairness, Dme distances from the VOR are on the approach chart, thus satisfying the altitude cross-check)
P.S. There is plenty of muppetry on the airborne side of the RTF too - throwing stones doesn't help and will come back and bite you.....ahh, is that three mixed metaphors in one postscript???
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: uk
Posts: 194
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What approach DID you brief for then in the absence of any being stated on the ATIS? There are a selection available - did you take your best guess? 
I thought that it was only a couple of button presses to re select the FMS - if it takes too much effort and thinking to do maybe you should have asked to be held while you sorted that out in order to prevent a rushed approach.
Spittoon -
louby
I thought that it was only a couple of button presses to re select the FMS - if it takes too much effort and thinking to do maybe you should have asked to be held while you sorted that out in order to prevent a rushed approach.
Spittoon -
louby
PEACOCK
I find your description of ATC professional very very inappropriate and insulting---Muppet is one of the worst thing to be called on Pprune---them's fightin' words brother
---I agree you should change the title---take deep breaths ahhhh
LOOBYLOU MY SINCEREST APOLOGIES
I find your description of ATC professional very very inappropriate and insulting---Muppet is one of the worst thing to be called on Pprune---them's fightin' words brother
---I agree you should change the title---take deep breaths ahhhhLOOBYLOU MY SINCEREST APOLOGIES
Last edited by Pugilistic Animus; 30th Apr 2008 at 13:09. Reason: DIRECTING MY IRE AT THE WRONG POSTER
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: California USA
Posts: 719
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A matter of interpretation perhaps. I don't read it as saying that the ILS is U/S but rather it is the DME associated with the ILS that is broke.
I had to read your post a couple of times as well before I grasped the point you were trying to make, and I've got to agree with Spitoon: If I read that ATIS cold, I'd conclude that the DME was out but that the ILS (sans DME) was still on the air and usable.
Granted, it could have been stated more clearly ("DME I-NN U/S" as suggested perhaps?), but the lashing you provided seems a bit much.
Dave
PS Pug... I believe you're directing your ire at the wrong poster...
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Manchester
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The "AIR" ATSA has the responsibility of "checking" the content of the ATIS/DATIS. If he/she has been informed [by Tels......via the Tower Supervisor] that xyz is OOS....then that is what is broadcast.
If a piece of kit then becomes "Serviceable" and the AIR ATSA is not informed then [unfortunately] the "old" information is still transmitted.
If in doubt CHECK...with APC perhaps.
bb
If a piece of kit then becomes "Serviceable" and the AIR ATSA is not informed then [unfortunately] the "old" information is still transmitted.
If in doubt CHECK...with APC perhaps.
bb
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: uk
Posts: 1,122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wonder if it's what an ILS approach is called has something to do with it.At our UK unit we call it an ILS approach.However overseas I heard it called an ILS/DME .The R/T used there was ''Cleared ILS/DME approach''.Perhaps if they hear that phraseology used,then copy an ATIS that says RWY23R ILS DME is u/s,then they could misunderstand that the ILS ,and it's procedure was not available.(perhaps)
However we inform the aircraft on first contact what type of approach they can expect.If they had briefed for an alternative approach,then why not carry on with that,as long as the wx is within limits.
)However we inform the aircraft on first contact what type of approach they can expect.If they had briefed for an alternative approach,then why not carry on with that,as long as the wx is within limits.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: The foot of Mt. Belzoni.
Posts: 2,001
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1. What is a digital ATIS printout and how is it obtained?
2. Is the loss of the ILS DME such a big issue? For many years, ILS facilities had no associated DME. OK there were marker beacons, but surely a rough range from touchdown is obtainable from the glideslope angle (ie 350, 650, 950ft plus the threshold elevation etc), or maybe from the navigation display or, as a last resort, by asking the approach radar controller.
2. Is the loss of the ILS DME such a big issue? For many years, ILS facilities had no associated DME. OK there were marker beacons, but surely a rough range from touchdown is obtainable from the glideslope angle (ie 350, 650, 950ft plus the threshold elevation etc), or maybe from the navigation display or, as a last resort, by asking the approach radar controller.
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: California USA
Posts: 719
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Easy there, FinDir... Play the ball, not the man. Take the high road, else be prepared to get some of your own medicine. Remember, what comes around goes around. Don't be too quick on the trigger. Strive to avoid being all heat and no light. For after all is said and done, more is said than done. Remember, even a hare will bite when it is cornered. Examine what is said, not him who speaks. Above all, don't speak unless you can improve on the silence [Insert other idioms/proverbs/metaphors as appropriate].
Dave
ATCer
Dave
ATCer
Guest
Posts: n/a
Is the loss of the ILS DME such a big issue? For many years, ILS facilities had no associated DME. OK there were marker beacons, but surely a rough range from touchdown is obtainable from the glideslope angle (ie 350, 650, 950ft plus the threshold elevation etc), or maybe from the navigation display or, as a last resort, by asking the approach radar controller.
