PDA

View Full Version : Pilot Sues For Forced Retirement


Pages : 1 [2]

Sailvi767
4th Sep 2018, 12:50
This is funny! You are more likely to die than being incapacitated?



https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-45096074


keep in mind the stats you quote are for life span average from birth. The meaningful stat you actually need to quote is expected remaining lifespan for someone already 65. Its considerable higher than total average lifespan. The longer you live the longer you can expect to live.

Nightstop
4th Sep 2018, 12:56
If Wayne’s crowdfund fails to achieve his target, does that mean the case against the CAA is off?

beamer
4th Sep 2018, 13:27
Whatever Wayne's motives might be, and they surely cannot be financial, I suspect that a ruling in his favour will not change the UK aviation scene that much and some form of appeal from the CAA would surely be inevltable putting the whole issue on hold for a further period of time.

The majority of pilots of my acquaintance have ceased commercial flying before getting to the age of 65. That being said, for every final salary fatcat ( that sounds harsh but its not meant to be ! ) there may well be a pilot who has been through the divorce process, raised a second family or perhaps been made redundant upon multiple occasions or seen their pensions shredded as in Monarch. Even in the latter sets of circumstances the prospect of working, even if part-time, may well be unpalatable for many. I do know pilots who would have continued after their 'enforced' retirement age but their numbers are dwarfed by those who got out at the first viable opportunity.

Would a change in the rules to a higher upper age limit of say 68 or 70 have a huge impact on times to command ? Personally I doubt it for the simple reason that, in my opinion at least, the take-up rate would not be very high. Complications with regulations imposed by other nation states could mean that the effective use of a higher age limit from the British Courts would be limited. Would pilots, already over 65, be rushing to find jobs having been away from flying for some time, again, I doubt it and the question of who would employ them and in what capacity would be an interesting one to answer.

If Wayne's campaign is unsuccessful, there will still be opportunities for non-flying roles such as simulator instructors ( the age of some around LGW never ceased to amaze me ! ) whilst the world of light-aircraft and simple pleasure flying awaits for those who need a regular fix.

Having already taken the decision to retire early ( no final-salary or Ferrari ) I have no particular axe to grind on this one but it may be that this is an opportune time to take on the CAA which some people tell me is in a state of permanent chaos

beardy
4th Sep 2018, 14:10
The RAF mirror the CAA. Certain roles could be extended beyond the current limit of 65, if the CAA altered their rules. (Instructing and AEF flying spring to mind)

w.bayley
4th Sep 2018, 16:51
Nightstop,
It will not fail to reach its target. But the more successful it is the better our prospects become.

As for comments on an Appeal. It isn't in the public interest to defend this challange. Going to Court mearly offers an opportunity to expose the fact that the CAA had not performed one of its public duties. Appealing against a decision in our favour just offers up an increased prospect of someone loosing their job.

Fbwdude
4th Sep 2018, 19:10
Hi all,
I am from Brazil and as long as you pass your medical and your pc you are ok to fly( domestic routes of course).
There are some 71 year old captains flying at GOL AIRLINES and also at LATAM( 69,I believe).
I thing there should be no restrictions regarding age , I also thing it`s a matter of choice and no one should have the right to make that decision but yourself.
Some guys have lost their provident fund due to previous companies bankrupcy( VARIG,VASP and TRANSBRASIL) and have no other option and some others just want to keep on flying.
My two cents.
Fly safe.

A340Yumyum
4th Sep 2018, 23:28
Nightstop,
It will not fail to reach its target.

https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/equality-for-pilots


I reckon you’re short of £34,930?

w.bayley
5th Sep 2018, 20:37
A340 Yum Yum
Try Crowd Justicenotoagediscrimination. 😁

bad bear
6th Sep 2018, 16:15
I also support you Wayne. A totally arbitrary cut off age is simply wrong.

I could accept age being part of a matrix of factors that would decide when a pilot has to stop but not age alone. The 2 main issues are competence and health so a matrix that starts at age 60 where the pilot has 150 point then looses 5 per year till he is 65 the 10 points per year till 70 then 15 per year till the end while also loosing points for sub average scores on training and a disproportionate number for totally failing a second check could with similar deductions for being in a risk category health wise i.e over weight, unhealthy life style, unable to run 5 km etc would attract similar deductions. This matrix would mean that some underperforming and unhealthy pilots would be retired before 65 and those who work hard to maintain their standards and are functioning well enough to do so and making the effort ( possibly having the good luck) to stay fit and active could work on till 75 ish (almost certainly part time).

From what ive seen in my career most pilots don't go chasing hosties and are faithful to their partner so don't deserve the financial hit they take when marriage breaks down, its often precisely because the pilot is away working trying to provide for his wife and family that the partner chooses to leave because the pilot is not at home enough, cant commit to social occasions like other professions or when he is home he is tired from the early starts and long days

For the young pilots coming through thinking the older guys are" bed blocking", not all the old pilots have had an easy career and many do still need to work. In my younger days it was not uncommon to meet pilots who had been laid off 5 times in 10 years and spent much of that time commuting to a different airport every year and earning next to nothing.Even being trained by BA was not a golden ticket and many pilots were redeployed to other jobs with a very slow start to their career and waited decades for command. Many of the young pilots today might be glad of working a few more years past 65 when their time comes once they see what life has dealt them. Certainly the younger pilots will have poorer pensions than the few lucky guys who made it through their career on a final salary scheme, given the cost of buying a house many pilots will still be paying their mortgages off in their 70's

A job is not just a way of earning money, nor is it necessarily about "status" its a great buzz to fly modern aeroplanes, visiting interesting places and working with intelligent and capable people...... all those thing i will miss when i eventually retire. I have good hobbies, keep really fit,have a great circle of friends but finishing my working life will leave a big hole that will be hard to fill and having lost my pension through no fault of my own (these things do still happen just ask and Monarch, BMI of many other pilots), I do need to keep earning past 65.



bb

Biggles78
6th Sep 2018, 19:06
A 777 with one engine out is probably safer than a Vickers Vimy with two
I dear say it is considering a Vickers Vimy is a magnificent twin engine flying machine. :)

Who remembers FEDEX 705. An interview with one of the pilots who had to take anti seizure tablets and so couldn't fly said he missed the profession. He missed the camaraderie of his fellow pilots and the flying. He mentioned nothing about thinking of wanting to retire when he was 31 like some new poster. In a nutshell, he loved his profession and wanted to keep doing it but was stopped by one selfish bastard.

Then there was the guy who did pipeline or power line patrols in a J3 or PA18. 52,000 hours and 3 days after retirement, he died. Did he die from a medical condition or was his passion stolen from him because he reached 70?

If you love what you are doing then why not keep on doing it until medically unable. In this thread we have what appear to be middle age pilots who can't wait to pull the plug. Then why not do it now and toddle of and do something that you do like. You may just live longer and be a lot happier than you appear to indicate in your posts.

I wish Captain Bayley all the best in his endeavour to keep aloft.