Circling in GOA

[Topper80]

Hi all,

looking at the approach procedures in GOA (LIMJ) I noticed that in case of a circling for rwy 10 after an ILS 28, for cat D airplanes, the MDA is 2860 ft, while performing the same circling after a VOR 28, the MDA is just 1700 ft. Do you know why? :ugh:
In case I expect a circling for 10, I will request to perform a VOR 28 instead of ILS 28!
:*

[Cough]

On our charts the VOR is also 1700' for cat D with IAS less than 185kt, staying inside a fixed distance from the SES or GSE.

On the ILS chart, we also have 2860 annotated for Cat D ias > 185kt. For less than 185kt, you get referred to a circling minima chart which allows 1700' provided you stay inside a fixed distance again.

So no advantage to the VOR...

[michelda]

Dear all,
In my limj charts (01.04.11), circling minima for ils and vor are same value.
I can not understand note 4 and minima for cat D a/m. It looks like to different values and I don't know why!!

Ciao
Michelda