PDA

View Full Version : C182 crash lands on toilets - pilot uninjured


TacomaSailor
2nd May 2009, 15:15
I was watching flight operations at Thun Field (Pierce County Airport KPLU – Pierce County Washington USA) May 1 at about 15:30 PDT. I had been watching two Cessna pilots prepare their aircraft for flight. It was apparent they were planning to fly together. I was standing at the fuel dock about mid- runway.

The first plane took off on runway 34 (3600’ x 60’) followed 20 seconds later by the second Cessna. It was clear and calm, about 72° Fahrenheit. As the 2nd plane climbed through 100 feet I heard a distinct “clunk” and saw the Cessna level out. At that point the plane was still over the north end of the runway at about 150’.

Then the pilot tried to return to the runway. He banked 40 degrees left, let the nose drop and then completed a 240° turn while rapidly descending. The last I saw of the plane was as it disappeared behind the hangers to my north. I then saw a wing pointed straight up, a cloud of dust, and the vertical stabilizer flash over the top of the low hanger.

I rushed to the crash site and found the Cessna on it’s back facing NW. A few seconds later the pilot climbed out of the cabin and walked toward the half dozen spectators. He was apparently uninjured.

The reason the pilot escaped injury was that the left wingtip had impacted on a porta-pot (Sanican, Honeybucket, portable toilet) and caused the plane to cartwheel. The fortunate thing for the pilot was the area was filled with hundreds of the plastic porta-pots and the plane landed upside down on them and crushed quite a few of them, each acting as a shock absorber. Eventually the plane came to rest with the nose on a porta-pot and the fuselage on a 6’ high pile of soft wood chips.

Here is a link to pictures of the porta-pot landing.
Seattle, WA News Channel - News in Seattle, Washington and the Pacific Northwest - KIRO (http://www.kirotv.com/news/index.html)

Deeday
2nd May 2009, 18:43
He must have literally sh**ed himself.
A pilot in the US managed to avoid injury when his plane dropped from the sky after its fall was cushioned by a row of portable toilets.
The Cessna 182 plane had taken off from Thun Field airfield in Pierce County before the engine apparently failed.
As it fell, the plane hit a fence, flipped upside down and landed on toilets being stored near the runway by the Northwest Cascade company.
A company employee said the toilets had "kind of cushioned things".
Ed Troyer, a spokesman for the county sheriff, told the News Tribune newspaper that the pilot had reached an altitude of about 150ft (46m) when the engine "quit running".
"He tried to turn around and come back and land, but he didn't quite make it," said Mr Troyer.The 67-year-old pilot, who was reported to have been flying alone, has not been identified.
BBC article (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/8030898.stm) with video.

Flyluke
2nd May 2009, 19:07
Quotation :
.He tried to turn around and come back and land, but he didn't quite make it,'

From 150' ?

I'm not surprised he didn't

Michael Birbeck
2nd May 2009, 19:17
My instructor always advised me against trying that "impossible" turn back at EFATO. I have since debated this with many people, some who claim that they would and could turn back successfully below 500 feet. I must admit I always brief that I will attempt to land ahead although at some airfields the options in front are pretty bleak.

I wonder if he spun in or just stalled before impacting the ground. The aircraft looks reasonably intact. I suspect he did not have much of a ground speed at the point of impact. The toilets were an added bonus I guess.

Michael Birbeck
2nd May 2009, 20:10
TACOMASAILOR saw the crash.

http://www.pprune.org/private-flying/372393-landing-upside-down-porta-pot.html

Sounds like he spun in. Very lucky to walk away.

clicker
2nd May 2009, 21:44
BBC NEWS | World | Americas | US plane crash lands on toilets (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/8030898.stm)

is a story of a Cessna crash landing on some porta loos in the US.

Picture shows the aircraft upside down and so landing in the muck can be lucky.

soay
3rd May 2009, 07:34
ANN had some fun with their headline for this story:

Powerless Plane Plummets Perilously, Pummeling Porta-Potties (http://www.aero-news.net/index.cfm?ContentBlockID=56661f50-2586-4fc3-960e-de2352ca7740&)

JW411
3rd May 2009, 08:09
I wonder if he trained with No 617 Squadron - otherwise known as "The Bogbusters"?

Icare9
3rd May 2009, 09:21
Definitely a crap landing!
Are you so sure it was a pile of wood chips he landed in?
At least he came away smelling of roses (not!!)
I think his friends will be keeping upwind of him for a few weeks!
"Hey, we're upside down" "How do you know we're upside down?" "Cos the sh*ts trickling down my neck!!"

ShyTorque
3rd May 2009, 18:47
Hope he called PAN PAN......

Old Photo.Fanatic
3rd May 2009, 18:59
As the saying goes "****e happens"!!!!!:yuk::yuk::yuk:

airborne_artist
3rd May 2009, 20:16
Was it a bog-standard C-182?

Know he knows why Cessna-haters call them Cesspits...

flybydayuk
3rd May 2009, 20:23
Ah yes but did you notice that the shi**y landing occurred near a place called Puyallup (honest!)
BBC NEWS | World | Americas | Plane crashes into portable toilets (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/8030826.stm)

Sthisland1
3rd May 2009, 21:54
Do the investigators have anything to go on?

stickandrudderman
4th May 2009, 09:21
I think he was one of the new breed of Kami Kazi!

Michael Birbeck
4th May 2009, 09:34
semper in excretum est sed alta variat

apruneuk
4th May 2009, 10:43
As usual, plenty of speculation before the Investigators have done their job. I am sure that, given time, they will get to the bottom of the matter and flush out the truth.

Runaway Gun
4th May 2009, 16:52
I bet the fan hit the sh*t.

MedusaThrills
4th May 2009, 19:47
What a crap landing
ahhh i was hoping someone hadnt said that :( Great minds think alike ;)

GOLF_BRAVO_ZULU
5th May 2009, 09:24
These chaps were legendary aviators;

http://www.century-of-flight.net/Aviation%20history/daredevils/images2/11.jpg

and they, too, landed in a bog;

http://www.century-of-flight.net/Aviation%20history/daredevils/images2/8.jpg

Fly-by-Wife
5th May 2009, 09:38
True, they were Alcock and White when they took off...

FBW

deltayankee
5th May 2009, 10:33
Instructors everwhere must be banging their heads on the glareshield! How many times have they said not to turn back like that and did it do any good? Not a bit.

Another point: maybe airports could buys surplus toilets and spread them on the ground at both ends of the runway to soften the bump after EFATO incidents.