Of 25 yr-old commanders and heavy equipment
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of 25 yr-old commanders and heavy equipment
Hi, all
is it possible that today there's some place in mother Africa where twenty-somethings routinely take command of factory-new jet transports and with TLC galore from grateful patrons to boot? And I'm not talking half-baked products, but professionals with sound acumen and a confident knowledge of their place in history.
Such was common in Nigeria of much of the seventies. Its military government was peopled by types fresh from a three-year war and yet unspoiled by the obsession with the public purse that marred later years.
Then, a model training institute, CATC Zaria, in Nigeria's far north, turned out ATC, A&C, Nav Aid, pilot and other staff for the national carrier and others' from as far afield as Malaysia, Sri Lanka and the East African trio. CATC had been set up with considerable UN/ICAO help in in 1963, and maintained an excellent reputation till the late eighties. It housed Nigeria Airways' F-28 simulator.
The good times obviously were a product of spiralling commodity prices, but the truth is, the industry was in its infancy and as such, local pilots were a celebrated few. Public policy also dictated an airport for every state capital of the federation, which occured as Nigeria Airways recorded one of the highest growth rates worldwide (1976-'77).
To match the needs of the rapidly expanding middle-class, the government handed the airline a B707, two DC-10 30s, two B727-200s, five Fokker F-28 2000/4000s and an F-27 500, all cutting edge equipment then, in a space of 30 months. My native Benin City enjoyed a Lagos shuttle which, at ten rotations per day, barely met demand.
What makes it the more striking is the fact that the already high command time was not reduced [please correct me if I'm wrong]. To the contrary, McDonnel Douglas' in-house journal featured a Nigerian who attained DC-10 Captainship at 29, a world record.
Modest maintenance facilities (run by locals) in Lagos, did F-27/F-28 to C-checks alongside some component work (powerplants always went abroad).
Safety presented a clean sheet too, blurred only by the mid-air involving a military jet on approach to Kano in 1977, which was blamed on the other side.
The combination of factors earned that set of gentlemen an enviable lifestyle, never mind the fact that they were a much treasured elite.
But is there such anywhere out there today?
I'd be much honoured if you gentlemen would discuss it.
is it possible that today there's some place in mother Africa where twenty-somethings routinely take command of factory-new jet transports and with TLC galore from grateful patrons to boot? And I'm not talking half-baked products, but professionals with sound acumen and a confident knowledge of their place in history.
Such was common in Nigeria of much of the seventies. Its military government was peopled by types fresh from a three-year war and yet unspoiled by the obsession with the public purse that marred later years.
Then, a model training institute, CATC Zaria, in Nigeria's far north, turned out ATC, A&C, Nav Aid, pilot and other staff for the national carrier and others' from as far afield as Malaysia, Sri Lanka and the East African trio. CATC had been set up with considerable UN/ICAO help in in 1963, and maintained an excellent reputation till the late eighties. It housed Nigeria Airways' F-28 simulator.
The good times obviously were a product of spiralling commodity prices, but the truth is, the industry was in its infancy and as such, local pilots were a celebrated few. Public policy also dictated an airport for every state capital of the federation, which occured as Nigeria Airways recorded one of the highest growth rates worldwide (1976-'77).
To match the needs of the rapidly expanding middle-class, the government handed the airline a B707, two DC-10 30s, two B727-200s, five Fokker F-28 2000/4000s and an F-27 500, all cutting edge equipment then, in a space of 30 months. My native Benin City enjoyed a Lagos shuttle which, at ten rotations per day, barely met demand.
What makes it the more striking is the fact that the already high command time was not reduced [please correct me if I'm wrong]. To the contrary, McDonnel Douglas' in-house journal featured a Nigerian who attained DC-10 Captainship at 29, a world record.
Modest maintenance facilities (run by locals) in Lagos, did F-27/F-28 to C-checks alongside some component work (powerplants always went abroad).
Safety presented a clean sheet too, blurred only by the mid-air involving a military jet on approach to Kano in 1977, which was blamed on the other side.
The combination of factors earned that set of gentlemen an enviable lifestyle, never mind the fact that they were a much treasured elite.
But is there such anywhere out there today?
I'd be much honoured if you gentlemen would discuss it.
Join Date: May 2002
Location: South Africa
Posts: 91
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A Full Twenty Five??
Should the 25 year olds not still be flying light Piston twins in order to get some experience?? maybe learn about the weather, other african countries, operations and facilities. It is an absolute farce that little boys without the much needed experience in every aspect of aviation get to fly heavy equipment. It's a blooming Dogshow!
Go play with some toy aeroplanes!
Aginnintonnixadaykeepsadoctaaway!
Go play with some toy aeroplanes!
Aginnintonnixadaykeepsadoctaaway!
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Down the airway.
Posts: 689
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Trouble might be that not always has the Captain spent five years in the RHS before becoming a Captain before flying with one of the 10 hour 'God's gift to aviation' - in reality computer operators for whom Airbuses were invented. This flagrant sort of comment opens perhaps a can of the worms-nothing to do with Martin Luther-and passengers might be inclined to wonder why it is that certain Airbuses in certain flight modes are rumored not to be able to be auto pilot disengaged by the flight crew.
As for air force pilots in their mid twenties in charge of sophisticated equipment-well, it is rumoured that so long as no one is injured-well, what is another €/£/$ or two of the tax payers' money? Furthermore-more flagration-have you ever flown with one of these death or glory boys, straight out of his super fast jet (know of any slow jets?) into the RHS -or LHS - in a European or North American winter. Yessir!..talk about single crew operations in a hostile environment?
Not always of course-but then once time is enough perhaps to tarnish with the dripping brush the rest of the motley crew?
As for air force pilots in their mid twenties in charge of sophisticated equipment-well, it is rumoured that so long as no one is injured-well, what is another €/£/$ or two of the tax payers' money? Furthermore-more flagration-have you ever flown with one of these death or glory boys, straight out of his super fast jet (know of any slow jets?) into the RHS -or LHS - in a European or North American winter. Yessir!..talk about single crew operations in a hostile environment?
Not always of course-but then once time is enough perhaps to tarnish with the dripping brush the rest of the motley crew?
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Abroad
Posts: 1,172
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Should the 25 year olds not still be flying light Piston twins in order to get some experience?
Last edited by LH2; 10th Jun 2009 at 10:06. Reason: Mispelling
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Samsonite Avenue
Posts: 1,538
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I got my first command (BAe 146) when I was 24. Plenty other people get their commands at a similar age nowadays. It is now nothing special and I think most people now accept that it is part and parcel of the industry!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: South Africa
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Unfortunately at the age of 25 the average man is not experienced enough in life to be taking on the responsibilities required. It’s not about how Chuck Norris his abilities are but more about his ability to make critical decisions even before take-off about the flight and to counter others who may have 30 or 40 years experience in the flying game. Will they be able to do it, I doubt it.
Additionally, if some feel ‘droning’ around in a light twin on unscheduled, differing flights every day into different aerodromes having no radar guidance or auto pilot with less then half the navigation equipment found in most airliners helps nobody now days, then we have lost touch with what skills are required to perform our jobs as pilots. Sure your monkey see monkey do pilot can push the right buttons and read back clearances all while looking and sounding very cool but in my opinion under that exterior what we have is someone not experienced enough to deal with any curve balls thrown at him. Sure he will have had simulator training for certain scenarios but then so would our twin piston pilot once in the same seat, except, he would bring say 5 years of general aviation experience with him to the fight.
Additionally, if some feel ‘droning’ around in a light twin on unscheduled, differing flights every day into different aerodromes having no radar guidance or auto pilot with less then half the navigation equipment found in most airliners helps nobody now days, then we have lost touch with what skills are required to perform our jobs as pilots. Sure your monkey see monkey do pilot can push the right buttons and read back clearances all while looking and sounding very cool but in my opinion under that exterior what we have is someone not experienced enough to deal with any curve balls thrown at him. Sure he will have had simulator training for certain scenarios but then so would our twin piston pilot once in the same seat, except, he would bring say 5 years of general aviation experience with him to the fight.
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Down the airway.
Posts: 689
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Obviously is not necesssarily so and also you beg the question a little bit there?
The thing is that the technical stuff, airborne and ground based has all improved very tremendously over the last twenty years. Whether this has allowed a sub standard species of pilot, compared to those who flew aircraft that regularily gave trouble and had to think for themselves, to enter the cockpits of todays totally automated Airbus is another saga. Perhaps what is not being acquired by experiencing flying before computer games is the development of that innate sixth sense which comes from flying all over the place (literally if you like) and which has got so many of our backsides out of the pyhton pit-including, I suspect, that guy in the Hudson (you know, the river, not the car).
Also-to say that it is normal in Europe for pilots to have command of aircraft in their mid twenties and that Europe has a far better safety record than Africa is a non sequitur. Africa has lousy maintainance and terrible radar/ground controlers. (SA excepted of course). And in Europe they do and we did, fly aircraft without working radar or half the navigation aids not to mantion auto pilot problems. We just were not allowed to but would have been in big trouble with managment if we had grounded the aircraft. What got us through most of the time? That hard learnt experience that tickles your sleepy old brain when something is just not quite right.
And then you get two of the greenhorns in the same cockpit?
The thing is that the technical stuff, airborne and ground based has all improved very tremendously over the last twenty years. Whether this has allowed a sub standard species of pilot, compared to those who flew aircraft that regularily gave trouble and had to think for themselves, to enter the cockpits of todays totally automated Airbus is another saga. Perhaps what is not being acquired by experiencing flying before computer games is the development of that innate sixth sense which comes from flying all over the place (literally if you like) and which has got so many of our backsides out of the pyhton pit-including, I suspect, that guy in the Hudson (you know, the river, not the car).
Also-to say that it is normal in Europe for pilots to have command of aircraft in their mid twenties and that Europe has a far better safety record than Africa is a non sequitur. Africa has lousy maintainance and terrible radar/ground controlers. (SA excepted of course). And in Europe they do and we did, fly aircraft without working radar or half the navigation aids not to mantion auto pilot problems. We just were not allowed to but would have been in big trouble with managment if we had grounded the aircraft. What got us through most of the time? That hard learnt experience that tickles your sleepy old brain when something is just not quite right.
And then you get two of the greenhorns in the same cockpit?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
the "boys" were well trained, silly
In fact CATC was de facto a University; the scholarly bent was reflected in the dim view its products took of US-trained peers, untill they discovered the Yanks could fly every bit well as they, though. Two good years it took to get qualified (sorry I cant say for sure, but I think it was CPL/multi/inst). They were mostly government sponsored.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hats off to you, sir
de absolute hammer needs read your two lines, boss. The relative in this case was heavily influenced by training as good as could be found anywhere else world-wide {look, the UN/ICAO played no small role and some of their managerial and technical/teaching staff didnt depart till the late seventies}. Graduands could not but be good. Relatives also showed up in motivation and such drive that went with being members of an elite corps
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
... yo, yo, yo, !!!!!!!!!
Oompilot and de absolute hammer dont get it do they? It's about competence, aptitude, and as I take pains to stress, motivation, {as only the cash-rich government of a developing country can provide}
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
De absolute Hammer, what's the grouse?
Am not absolutely sure at the moment (and I'll find out and try get back to you), but Nigeria Airways of the early seventies couldn't have accepted much less than 4000 hrs for command, if at all. Most of its pioneer pilots were ex-BOAC; it wasnt until mid/late sixties that Polish and South African pilots appeared. So, standards were high. I think you should adopt the opinion of Flyer 14
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"... nothing new now in europe"
is all I was after, more or less. That a dream life is said pilot's is something for which to be thankful to Goodness for them, dont you think? Thanks for the info, JanetFlight 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Down the airway.
Posts: 689
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Oh dear...
So in the seventies Nigeria took the best and the brightest from its military, experienced through three years of war. It put those recruits through a totally state funded two year university type course, in large part set up and operated by ICAO/United Nation staff, complete with their own in house jet simulator, leading to a pilot licence. Once these students graduated from this pleasant sounding place they were rightly accorded elite staus in Nigeria and flew for upwards of 4,000 hours with, at first, ex BOAC Captains and then Polish and South African Captains before transitioning themselves to the left hand seat.
Well-this is the Africa forum but generally speaking, it is probably lucky that most pilots in Europe do not really seem to need that sort of care and attention in order to get their wings these days.
So in the seventies Nigeria took the best and the brightest from its military, experienced through three years of war. It put those recruits through a totally state funded two year university type course, in large part set up and operated by ICAO/United Nation staff, complete with their own in house jet simulator, leading to a pilot licence. Once these students graduated from this pleasant sounding place they were rightly accorded elite staus in Nigeria and flew for upwards of 4,000 hours with, at first, ex BOAC Captains and then Polish and South African Captains before transitioning themselves to the left hand seat.
Well-this is the Africa forum but generally speaking, it is probably lucky that most pilots in Europe do not really seem to need that sort of care and attention in order to get their wings these days.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Benin City, Nigeria
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Take it easy, absolute Hammer.....
Sorry if I got you angry. I admit a lot of my feeling is nostalgia, and I do get going when I recall them days, which in many ways are better than now. That set of expats was mostly gone by the early 70s; the soldiers remained soldiers, it was young civies who learned to fly, but I guess it's mostly insight into the dynamics of developing societies we're talking here.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The wrong side of town.
Posts: 193
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Almal is n groot doos behalwe ons !
I cant believe how many people seem to react badly to the concept of a 25 year old heavy metal driver.
Many of the "Skygod Meneer Kapteine" would like the rest of humanity to believe that they are extremely profound individuals on account of their abilities to manage impressive bits of kit around the skies, then their own misconceptions about themselves gets blown out of the sky, every time any 4bar eppauletted, 20 something, snot nose kid climbs into a heavy jet and fly's 300 pax half way across the world equally as competantly and safely as any of the Skygods do.
Before anyone cries out the word "experience" or "emergency" again, remember that nowdays in modern airlines every thought and action that one has from sign on to sign off, is regulated and dictated from a pre-existing and pre-scribed set of rules, MOP's and SOP's ( all which must be obeyed lest you lose your job or fail your prof check), so ones massive intelligence and experience counts for little in any scenario because you have to do it by the book irrespective.
It is such a South African mentality and I hate to say this but particularly a way of thinking in the National airline that unless you "k@k'd off" in the right hand seat for 15 years first then you cant possibly be competant or mature enough to move across to the left side.
Looking at the average age of some of the Emirates (amongs other airlines) crew's proves otherwise.
A while ago a skygod was moaning about this exact thing stating that he had to "earn his stripes" sitting in the right hand seat for 15 years and so should everyone else in this industry.
People like that should remember that that mentality is from a different era and that the world is moving rapidly towards the year 2020, not backward into the 1980's.
To assume that someone cannot do your job as well as you , or better, simply beacuse they are much younger than you , is arrogant.
Many of the "Skygod Meneer Kapteine" would like the rest of humanity to believe that they are extremely profound individuals on account of their abilities to manage impressive bits of kit around the skies, then their own misconceptions about themselves gets blown out of the sky, every time any 4bar eppauletted, 20 something, snot nose kid climbs into a heavy jet and fly's 300 pax half way across the world equally as competantly and safely as any of the Skygods do.
Before anyone cries out the word "experience" or "emergency" again, remember that nowdays in modern airlines every thought and action that one has from sign on to sign off, is regulated and dictated from a pre-existing and pre-scribed set of rules, MOP's and SOP's ( all which must be obeyed lest you lose your job or fail your prof check), so ones massive intelligence and experience counts for little in any scenario because you have to do it by the book irrespective.
It is such a South African mentality and I hate to say this but particularly a way of thinking in the National airline that unless you "k@k'd off" in the right hand seat for 15 years first then you cant possibly be competant or mature enough to move across to the left side.
Looking at the average age of some of the Emirates (amongs other airlines) crew's proves otherwise.
A while ago a skygod was moaning about this exact thing stating that he had to "earn his stripes" sitting in the right hand seat for 15 years and so should everyone else in this industry.
People like that should remember that that mentality is from a different era and that the world is moving rapidly towards the year 2020, not backward into the 1980's.
To assume that someone cannot do your job as well as you , or better, simply beacuse they are much younger than you , is arrogant.
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Down the airway.
Posts: 689
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
To assume that someone cannot do your job as well as you , or better, simply beacuse they are much younger than you , is arrogant.
No it is not. It is the self preservation of supply and demand.
There is an over supply of young pilots and thus they demand that the older ones retire earlier to make way for them.
The implication or assumption you outline above is pure self defence to coun ter the arrogant assumption of youth that it is entitled to something by the virtue of that very youth.
No it is not. It is the self preservation of supply and demand.
There is an over supply of young pilots and thus they demand that the older ones retire earlier to make way for them.
The implication or assumption you outline above is pure self defence to coun ter the arrogant assumption of youth that it is entitled to something by the virtue of that very youth.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The wrong side of town.
Posts: 193
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The implication or assumption you outline above is pure self defence to coun ter the arrogant assumption of youth that it is entitled to something by the virtue of that very youth.
Today 19:04
Not at all sir,
A youngster automatically assuming that he is entitled to a position on account of his youth is just as arrogant as the skygod who assumes that the youngster is incompetant on account of his youth .
BTW I'm not a youngster myself, I have been told that I am late middle aged.
Today 19:04
Not at all sir,
A youngster automatically assuming that he is entitled to a position on account of his youth is just as arrogant as the skygod who assumes that the youngster is incompetant on account of his youth .
BTW I'm not a youngster myself, I have been told that I am late middle aged.