PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Accidents and Close Calls (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls-139/)
-   -   Passenger on Challenger Jet Dies from Turbulence (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/651661-passenger-challenger-jet-dies-turbulence.html)

Lake1952 5th Mar 2023 11:14

Passenger on Challenger Jet Dies from Turbulence
 
A passenger aboard a Challenger business jet died after the aircraft hit turbulence shortly after takeoff from Keene, NH on March 3. The plane diverted to Hartford.
https://www.wcvb.com/article/passeng...gland/43191524
https://apnews.com/article/turbulenc...7683ea26a0e855

WHBM 5th Mar 2023 12:19

It's very difficult to imagine how a SEATBELTED passenger can be fatally injured, but one wonders if those chartering private jets think they are somehow immune to Newton's Laws of dynamics.

I certainly recall an article a while ago of the large press party accompanying the USA President, not in AF1 but in a following chartered airliner, who said that quite a number of the journalists liked to smirkingly stand up during takeoff, because "it's our charter, so we don't have to do seatbelt rules and things. Yaa Boo !".

Lake1952 5th Mar 2023 13:06

I will bet dollars to dimes that the passenger was not belted in, but we will just have to wait for further details.

HOVIS 5th Mar 2023 15:49


Originally Posted by WHBM (Post 11395897)
It's very difficult to imagine how a SEATBELTED passenger can be fatally injured, but one wonders if those chartering private jets think they are somehow immune to Newton's Laws of dynamics.

I certainly recall an article a while ago of the large press party accompanying the USA President, not in AF1 but in a following chartered airliner, who said that quite a number of the journalists liked to smirkingly stand up during takeoff, because "it's our charter, so we don't have to do seatbelt rules and things. Yaa Boo !".

Do they still do the tea tray slide down the aisle on take off? 🙄

Lake1952 5th Mar 2023 18:06

I couldn't see anything unusual from this flight record except that from takeoff from KEEN to landing at KBDL took 25 minutes, yet it reached FL 260.

https://flightaware.com/live/flight/.../KBDL/tracklog


fitliker 5th Mar 2023 18:50


Originally Posted by Lake1952 (Post 11395925)
I will bet dollars to dimes that the passenger was not belted in, but we will just have to wait for further details.

They say the Princess would have survived the crash if she was wearing her seatbelt .

DaveReidUK 5th Mar 2023 21:13

Seatbelt rules, like any others, are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men ...

megan 6th Mar 2023 00:48

When would a wise person wear a seat belt Dave? :confused: Me, I wear a seat belt at all times, except for the walk to/from the loo and the loo doesn't have one.

sablatnic 6th Mar 2023 01:03


Originally Posted by megan (Post 11396171)
When would a wise person wear a seat belt Dave? :confused: Me, I wear a seat belt at all times, except for the walk to/from the loo and the loo doesn't have one.

Maybe he just indicates that obedient
fools tend to take off their seat belts when the light goes out.

Flch250 6th Mar 2023 10:26

Perhaps a medical emergency shortly before or after turbulence. Turbulence could have induced the medical emergency.

Mad (Flt) Scientist 6th Mar 2023 12:23


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 11396112)
Seatbelt rules, like any others, are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men ...

I believe he is saying that fools, who are unable to judge when to wear a seat belt, should just follow the rules, whereas "wise men" who understand the risks will (a) wear them even without rules, when appropriate and (b) will not wear them, again when judgement overrides the rule; thus the rule "guides" the wise.

Seat4A 6th Mar 2023 15:44


Piper_Driver 7th Mar 2023 14:49

Victim identified. It sounds from the quotes from her spouse as though passengers were thrown around the cabin. This implies no seat belts were being used.

Turbulence victim

megan 8th Mar 2023 00:58


Maybe he just indicates that obedient fools tend to take off their seat belts when the light goes out
If they're relying on the light then they're not taking any notice of the verbal recommended advice to belt up when seated, fools have an option as to which advice they heed, verbal good, light not good. I may well be stoopid myself, fail to see why not wearing the expensively provided accessory (seatbelt) is an issue. Old accident.

Greece's deputy foreign minister and five others were killed when the Greek Government-owned Dassault Falcon 900B presidential jet suffered an unexplained flight incident on descent into Bucharest, Romania on 14 September.The Falcon 900 (SX-ECH) descended rapidly from 15,000ft (4,600m) to 2,000ft, where the crew recovered control.

Although turbulence was blamed at first, local reports and the world meteorological centre at Bracknell, UK, confirm that there was no storm activity or extensive cumulonimbus cloud in that area, nor jetstream activity at that level.

The aircraft is operated by Olympic Airways for the Greek government. There were 13 people on board, and as well as the five fatalities, three passengers suffered severe injury. A journalist who was strapped into his seat reports that the aircraft was "moving like a boat in a rough sea", and that passengers had been thrown violently at the cabin ceiling.

Most of the passengers were not strapped in and the minister was standing when the incident occurred. A pilot who examined the aircraft on the ground after its arrival at Bucharest says that it did not appear to have suffered external structural damage.

nevillestyke 8th Mar 2023 08:35


Originally Posted by WHBM (Post 11395897)
It's very difficult to imagine how a SEATBELTED passenger can be fatally injured, but one wonders if those chartering private jets think they are somehow immune to Newton's Laws of dynamics.

I certainly recall an article a while ago of the large press party accompanying the USA President, not in AF1 but in a following chartered airliner, who said that quite a number of the journalists liked to smirkingly stand up during takeoff, because "it's our charter, so we don't have to do seatbelt rules and things. Yaa Boo !".

I remember, when I was very young, that a teenage boy was showing off, by standing up in the Bobs roller-coaster at Belle Vue (the largest roller-coaster in Europe, at the time), as it made its circuit. He died after being thrown from the car.

averow 11th Mar 2023 14:24


Originally Posted by Piper_Driver (Post 11397128)
Victim identified. It sounds from the quotes from her spouse as though passengers were throw around the cabin. This implies no seat belts were being used.

Turbulence victim

Indeed! I have had occasion to fly a lot as SLF in the last year for business. My seatbelt stays fastened the whole flight except for brief trips to the WC. One imagines if you are on a private business jet, with commodious accommodation that the open spaces would be quite tempting to explore. That or one thinks that the seatbelt rules don't apply to you.

pattern_is_full 11th Mar 2023 18:27


Originally Posted by averow (Post 11399583)
.... or one thinks that the seatbelt rules don't apply to you.

...or that the laws of physics don't apply to you. No smiley, because it was a tragic mistake.

BFSGrad 24th Mar 2023 21:10

Preliminary Report N300ER

Key points:

Incident not caused by turbulence
Multiple AP/trim faults prior to upset
Upset event initiated due to pilot implementation of QRC for primary stabilizer trim fail
Upset g forces +4.2 to -2.3
1st takeoff attempt rejected due to right pitot tube cover installed
2nd takeoff no V-speeds entered
Both pilots under 100 hours in type

Storm Girl 24th Mar 2023 21:51

So, what can possibly go wrong?

tdracer 24th Mar 2023 22:11


Originally Posted by BFSGrad (Post 11408267)
Preliminary Report N300ER
Key points:

Upset g forces +4.2 to -2.3

Those numbers are well in excess of the design limits and dangerously close to the ultimate load limits.
That airframe needs a complete structural inspection before it returns to service. It may even need to be scrapped...


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:16.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.