Originally Posted by
Mooncrest
It appears that the FE seat isn't, or wasn't, necessarily occupied by an actual Flight Engineer... Makes me wonder if the CAA and FAA have fairly flexible rules with the FE seat.
Moon,
Oh, we were "actual" F/Es by technical definition. We just weren't what we called professional flight engineers (PFE) or F/E crewmen with no pilot credentials or aspirations who did that as a life's work. The PFE commonly began life as a mechanic and were worth their weight in gold, particularly in the non-sked biz where you went places not having your own MTC personnel. If they didn't do actual repairs, they were valuable in supervising the repairs by whatever MTC people showed up to do needed work.
As for "flexible rules", they aren't. The position is defined and requires dedicated training and an FAA F/E license with recip, TP or TJ ratings. For us pilot/F/Es who hired on with carriers operating 3-crew airplanes (and intending a multi-decade career with said carrier), we took positions as demanded by manning requirements...and allowed by seniority...with the expectation of moving to a "window" seat in due course. Overall circumstances dictated when.
Not sure about the Caravelle. I asked the same question in a Caravelle thread but no one answered it.