Have travelled on AA several times over the years, last year was probably the last. Our flight to Phil was ok but on our next fight to TPA was stopped at the holding point because the loos were us. Our return though Chicago was also below par. B757 with no personal screens and a 2hr late departure are not good. This year we are going to Canada and our flight out is with Icelandair via KEF SEA to victoria BC so we will see. Our return is direct from SFO with TCX. the draw back with them is you have to pay to reserve a seat after you have booked your trip.
Cheers Sam