Originally Posted by
Capt Fathom
All I can suggest is stay out of other people's flightdecks. How would you like someone criticising your approach.
We don't have the full picture as to what is going on!
For example, the previous landing aircraft may have reported a large undershoot shear!
Who knows. I'm just uncomfortable with the finger pointing without knowing the facts and actually being there.
We don't know who the PF is. There is no personal judgement made.
This video serves as a discussion point. Maybe even a training aide.
Shutting down discussion is the worst outcome. No one learns that way.