Hi LOMCEVAC
It's probably my lack of care in choosing the right words. All I'm trying to say is that evidence introduced into a report should be accompanied with a critical evaluation - if only as a footnote or appendix. It is certainly hard to read sequential posts and keep context -- one tends to pick up on specific sentences and paragraphs which then tend to take a life of their own!
I believe the AAIB report is below the standard that the victims, industry and the pilot deserve.
As an illustration of that I pointed out that the accuracy of the radar track in the report is not discussed. That is just one illustration. There are others.
I have no idea of the significance of that to the conclusions - I am not competent to comment on the flying having (sadly) never flown a fast jet.
But, the lack of scrutiny concerns me.