Hi LOMCEVAK
Originally Posted by
LOMCEVAK
Lemain,
You say "I personally don't believe the AAIB report goes far enough". Within the remit of AAIB reports, which present data and analyse it, what else do you think should have been included? Opinion and speculation are quite deliberately, and correctly, not included in their reports.
Yes, and no. Unless there is some initial speculation vital clues and evidence can be missed. For example, the pilot's qualifications and medical are looked into speculatively. In this AAIB report there are some odd omissions. For example the radar track is taken as gospel. Did a radar expert check the system? There is no measuring system in existence that is 100% accurate - factors such as antenna location, nature of antenna, and the digital processing can be important. I don't see any explanation in the report yet the radar track is considered evidential.