ASKAFP
As has already been pointed out by those that were there he did not ask the passengers to vote on the airworthiness of his aircraft.
Clearly you have more information than I, as you feel able to comment on his professionalism. However, those who were present seem to feel he conducted himself professionally and with consideration for his passengers. But why let the facts get in the way of a good story!
As for the technical issues and legalities I am sure with all the publicity the CAA will have looked into the problem. As far as I know they have no problem with anything he did unless of course they are part of some cover-up as well!
