PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - POF Sample Question
View Single Post
Old 30th July 2003 | 16:06
  #2 (permalink)  
FlyingForFun

Why do it if it's not fun?
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,782
Likes: 12
From: Bournemouth
Ok, I'll give it a go. But this is way beyond anything I remember learning for the ATPL exams.

The first part is fairly simple. Yes, you do need to factor a vertical component of thrust, and a downward component of drag. The easiest way of doing this is to resolve all the forces relative to the aircraft (rather than the ground) - if you do it this way, T, L and D are all at right-angles to each other, and W is the only one that isn't. So you need to break W into the bit that oposes L, which is WcosA, and the bit that oposes T, which is WsinA, where A is the climb angle. All of this is fairly basic stuff, and is covered in PPL books such as Trevor Thom - although it makes a lot more sense with a diagram!

Now it starts getting more difficult.

We know that T=120kN.
We know that W=500kN.
We know that L=12D

The only force oposing L is the previously-calculated component of W:

L = WcosA = 500cosA

All the other forces are at right-angles to this one, along the thrust/drag line:

T = D + WsinA, or 120 = D + 500sinA. Re-arranging this gives us D = 120 - 500sinA

Since L = 12D, and L = 500cosA, we know that:

12D = 500cosA, or D = (500/12)cosA

We know have two formulae that give us D, so they must be equal:

120 - 500sinA = (500/12)cosA

Now, it's simply a case of solving this. But this is where my A-Level maths falls over, and I don't know where to go from here.

Fortunately, since it's a multi-choice question, we can simply put in each of the 4 values of A and see which one is the closest. The answers are given in terms of a gradient, so convert them to an angle by dividing by 100 then taking the inverse tangent. For answer b, 15.7% comes out as 8.9 degrees - and this fits the equation pretty much exactly. Answer = B.

I think.

Now I'm waiting for someone to come along with the easy method that I'd completely missed!

FFF
---------------
FlyingForFun is offline