Plane talking
I agree
I used to enjoy reading Ben Sandilands, more recently feeling pretty unimpressed.
Yes it's good to have independent reporting from people who care about our industry, however the tendency towards the dramatic over statements 'appalling' etc etc. does not help build an environment where we support each other towards improvement in the industry.
Yes it's appropriate to investigate incidents big and small. Yes it's appropriate to compel improvements where necessary. Yes it's necessary to provide training if required. Yes it's appropriate to hold organisations or individuals accountable if there is blatant incompetence or violations.
No it's not useful or constructive to tee off at people or organisations in an unconstructive way and without all the facts. This kind of reporting has a negative affect on the safety culture of our industry.
Rant over.