PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - B-738 Crash in Russia Rostov-on-Don
View Single Post
Old 26th Mar 2016, 12:17
  #774 (permalink)  
LlamaFarmer
 
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: UK
Posts: 3,793
Received 74 Likes on 45 Posts
Originally Posted by three miles
Originally Posted by Util BUS
At 6:03 the controller responds to their intention to climb to FL80 with "Roger" although this is non-standard terminology I would have accepted it to me "Approved" in that part of the world.
Roger is very much so ICAO standard terminology and means, I acknowledge receipt of your transmission.
It is NEVER a clearance, in no part of the world.

The required clearance would read: In case of go around climb to and maintain FL80.

I hope your airborne appearance is limited to simulator skies, otherwise I suggest to revisit an ICAO phraseology RT lesson asap.

I accept that, but therefore they acknowledged the intention to climb to FL80.

The fact they didn't deny a clearance to FL80 could have been interpreted as a clearance-by-omission.


I've never flown to Russia, but I know plenty of people who have, and their non-standardness extends beyond just units. Phraseology is not always from the ICAO textbook, and in this instance, whilst it should not be accepted as a clearance, it is very possible that the controller meant it as an approval.
LlamaFarmer is online now