I take it that being an old pilot means ones mentality is suspect, versus the superior mentality of a young pilot?
No, I 'm talking about the guys that think they are the real pilots because they used to fly DC3s/DC4s/... and think they would have done a better job at the controls of the Concorde on that particular day.
Implying that the crew did not do a good job ("chaos in the cockpit", "FE doomed the aircraft") when nothing else could have saved them (read the report, and take a look at the pictures), and bringing up this accident into this thread is very disrespectful to the victims and their families. I call it poor judgement from Clunckdriver.