Chesty Morgan you are missing the point here, just because your views differ from some of the others doesn't mean the others are wrong.
The beauty about this sub forum is you can find the positives and the negatives. This allows people to make a balanced decision if it's worth applying.
Wouldn't it be bad if for example you think you are joining a friendly airline with very quiet rosters and quick career progression.
Only to realise after your have joined; the airline grounds people left right and center, you work your arse off in the summer with the only constant being the continuous roster changes while only the winters are quiet and stable and only to realise when you apply for your upgrade only 40% makes the command selection because the company prefers direct entry captains.
Not that such an airline would exist but you can see why its beneficial to share both the positive and negative views, both being taken with a pinch of salt.