Stilton
Thank you for perfect example of entirely opinion based post with no evidence to back up any of it.
Wishful thinking will not change anything.
Your example could be turned around.
What if he had flown to the river and hit a boat killing all on board, and then computers suggest that he could have made the runway....?
Re judgement
Computers don't use judgement. They use factual physics based calculation. They will always beat a human for such things.
Re Skill
Can you fly at coffin corner as well as a computer? If you can, you have more "skill" than U2 pilots
Can you fly at a perfect speed height and heading better than a computer? If you can you need to start a super flying school.....
Re experience
Can you contain the repository of all computer pilots and instantly share that knowledge around the other pilots so nobody ever makes the same mistake twice, or are you doomed to keep re-learning all the same mistakes again and again..
p.s. I'm a pilot.