"Constructive discussion can be of enormous benefit in the meantime."
That would indeed be true, if we were in possession of all the facts, and it is patently obvious to most of us that we clearly are not.
Why can't all you armchair experts understand that the reason all the proper experts aren't commenting is that they are fully aware that all they really know is that they don't know enough to comment?
A prerequisite for a constructive discussion is to have all the relevant data. Without that, its all bulldust and speculation - IMHO of course.