Watching all of this as an interested observer I am amazed you guys are duking it out on a public forum. I offer a few pieces of advice -
Get a private forum to discuss Union and EBA related things.
Next EBA give the TWU a call and you may end up with a better result. The AFAP are only interested in getting your annual fees for the MBF. They have demonstrated time and time again they are willing to trade away conditions for short term $$.
Thirdly you guys need to look past the dollars. If you have already sold the farm to pay for the bonuses and pay rises, what the hell are you going to do next time around? The cupboard is bare!!