I'm late to the party on this thread
I haven't read all the comments on this thread, so if this has already been discussed here, I apologize.
Wasn't there quite a bit of discussion on a previous thread about the difference between the HUD depiction and the PAPI visual depiction?
As I recall she was using the HUD (for ILS info) and he was using the PAPI's, and the difference made it look to her that they were high.
They weren't out of whack on anything until the last 100 feet, it looks to me.
Regards,
OBD