Yes, good news indeed for Nutty. I hope it was a legitimate MRO...
Fox. The way I see it, and have always understood it, is that the Judge runs through the entries & picks his/her favorite. If it is duplicated, or a variation on someone else's theme, the original poster gets the chocolates. Invariably, many minds think alike...you know, a thousand Monkeys with a thousand keyboards etc...
Where legitimate angst occurs is when the Judge inadvertently misses the fact that they've awarded the prize to the person who put it up second.
But, at the end of the day, it's designed to be a little bit of fun on the forum. As far as I know, there's no genuine prizes (if there have been, forget all the above because I'll friken blow a gasket!!!)