First of all I would not want whatever I would do wrong in a similar situation been analysed in the court of Pprune but there is one thing that stood out for me as probably caused by stress hormones and a good learning moment of what not to do
The commander, without confirmation from the co-pilot, quickly shut down the right engine and discharged the fire extinguisher bottle.
Almost a Kegworth or another AirAsia due to too quick actions. Like my favourite TRE always used to say: have a coffee first, then shut the engine down...
So, to be clear: this is no judgement as it can happen to all of us and the ones claiming that it will not happen to them should mail their licences back to the Beehive!
