PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Autoland
Thread: Autoland
View Single Post
Old 21st Feb 2015, 13:28
  #23 (permalink)  
No Fly Zone
 
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: Or-E-Gun, USA
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Lightbulb Keyword here is "Emergency"

@ barronflyer: There are countless wonderful responses to your question, yet may are off-topic by introducing criteria not within you simple question.
Your question was:

"...if during an emergency, an AL could be Carried out without operators approval e.g in poor weather conditions, as long as it subscribes to the above criteria?..."

A few got it. (Those who did get it, responded with far fewer words. You pose an important question, complicated for some, but with a simple answer... The key word in your question is 'emergency,' not 'practice' or 'certificated.' As you should know, in a genuine emergency you should fly first, navigate and when able, certainly declare your emergency. (Offering the nature of the emergency is a damn good idea and this is not the time to be cool and understated: give as much information as you reasonably can!)
Even if unable to transmit a Mayday, if you believe that your airplane is in serious danger, you may - and should - do anything reasonably to return it to earth with a safe landing. You Do Not Need ANY permission(s), from ATC, company operations procedure, CAA certificates or any of that balderdash to safely land your aircraft. Communicating with ATC and other aircraft is a very good idea, when possible, but it is NOT required.
In the example that you cited, if the aircraft and airport have Auto Landing capability, and you know how to use it, IMO, this is a no permission required situation: Use what you have and fuss about the details after you are safely on the ground.
Is ditching a better/safer choice? Some may legitimately differ here, but IMO, if you have some Auto Landing capacity, I think it is a better choice than ditching. In the instant, Only You can make that decision - and thank God pilots are rarely faced with such choices.
So what is the best, safest, functional response to your question? Use Every skill and facility that you, the aircraft and the runway has available and hope (pray) for the best. In the most simple terms, do you need 'company approval' to execute an unapproved Auto Landing procedure - in an emergency? Not only no, but Hell No!
If you are a pilot, you should already understand this very simple answer. If not a pilot, perhaps a curious civilian, now you know. Basic air laws have many different ways to express the concept, but in a genuine or perceived emergency you, as the pilot in command, may do virtually anything necessary to safely return your airplane to earth. The only serious qualification that I'd add might be, '...without seriously endangering another aircraft...' In even more simple terms, if your aircraft is in serious danger, you own the airspace. In after the-the-fact investigations nearly the only criteria examined is whether your action was reasonable.
Flight Safety 'Rules' are extremely important guidelines. If you violate one or more in the interest of preserving life, be prepared to justify your action(s) by describing the circumstances of the moment. If you do so, your event is over. And if you do not properly explain your extreme action(s), be prepared to walk, rather than fly.
Yet once more back to the basic of Auto Landing without the certificate: of course you may. If you are successful, you'll be the hero of they day. And if you screw it up, you'll be crucified.
As you should also know, ,there are very few absolute rules when flying. (The only perfect rule that I know of is that if it goes up, it will come down. In all other cases, as dictated by government and company, you are expected to break them if the safety of your aircraft is at stake. I hope that is as clear as mud. The regulatory Gods will get me for this, but if you need the use the airspace or facilities in unconventional ways to assure a safe landing, please do so. How many redundant ways can I say it?

Last edited by No Fly Zone; 21st Feb 2015 at 13:39. Reason: Add partial quote from original question
No Fly Zone is offline