I followed the link to the discussion of landing a cherokee 180
Since it was closed, I have to point out here that the whol darn series is called a CHEROKEE with an add on for each version.
Cherokee Cruiser
Cherokee Warrior
Cherokee Archer
the 235 was called a Cherokee Pathfinder Or Cherokee Dakota
etc even cherokee arrow
and the Cherokee Six.
Call up atc and say: Piper 12345 six miles south landing with lima and they will ask you what kind of piper you are...cub, tripacer, navaho etc
or if you call up and say CHEROKEE 12345 six miles south landing with lima and they will know what to look for.
Difference in wings and horsepower are relatively minor things.