karnc
I am really aghast at your statements. Alternate law is no different than normal law except the protection part then why would Airbus not pitch up when you pull the stick? If that were to happen the aircraft wouldn't be allowed to fly.
Pilots with thousands of bus hours still have difficulty pulling a level 45 bank in altn or direct law. I am a sim instructor and believe me, i see this all the time.
Any body who wants to do 45 degrees turn in alternate law/direct law surely has to be out of his mind. You are not training A320 aerobatic team are you? You are wasting their precious SIM time. About piloting skills first you have to have them and they will stand by you the accidents we are discussing the pilots have shown alarming lack of it.