Joyce clearly doesn't want anyone with sound airline operational knowledge on his board as they may point out his and other board members lack of knowledge.
I also have no problem with Sampsons inclusion, I just have a problem with the entire makeup of the board. I don't expect a pilot or an engineer on the board, just at least one (preferably more) credible person(s) from a successful aviation background with significant operational knowledge.
I would also expect persons with significant accounting/banking & law experience, however we seem a little top heavy in these fields.
Mostly however, ditch the kool aid.
Independant, knowledgeable & passionate persons with Qantas' best interests at heart (not personal wealth).
Is this too much to ask?
Hopefully Sampson can prove to be this.