In May according to the NYTimes the United Nations sent auditors to Jakarta, Indonesia to rate the countries aviation safety record...their conclusion Indonesia's safety recorded was “well below...global average in every category...scoring 61 in airworthness”. (note it was not specific to AirAsia but to the country of Indonesia as a whole).
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/01/wo...airline-safety
Another article on the net indicates that the EU bars 62 Indonesian carriers into Europe for safety reasons. This article sites that the biggest issue/concern is proper training with rapidly aviation expansion.
My concerns with this accident is the fact that it is a “Low cost airline” and MAYBE not conclusive the push to get planes in the air vs canceling or delaying a flight as it would disrupt that particular planes day flight legs and the possible loss of revenue/increase cost in revenue that is required to move the pax if a flight is cancelled and the airline needs to sell the seats to another airline to move the pax to their destination.
All accidents are a domino effect as we know and I think the first domino in this case goes back to management wanting to keep airline cost down, then dispatch and obviously the flight crew. There is no discussion on here about dispatch and their role in moving this flight forward by 2 hours...clearly dispatch knew the weather was bad and getting worse...the question is was dispatch pressed to get the fight into the air vs canceling or delaying the flight due to weather. What kind of training and years of experience do AirAsia dispatchers have and how much pressure from management/dispatch in the very early am did the captain of this flight have/feel and/or was he to fatigue to make a proper decision to delay the flight.
As for the flight crew...at what time did they receive a revised call to leave their home for the new flight departure time was pushed 2 hours ahead (pilot fatigue). Were they a reserve crew? if so what kind of reserve structure does AirAsia have ie a/b/c reserve schedule.
As for the discussion about radar in cockpits...radars are behind the times not only in the airline industry but also in the corporate world...these aircraft/glass cockpit manufactures should have real time weather overlay like the handheld gps that the civil light aircraft owners use they are excellent at navigating around weather. It’s interesting to see even the Indonesia navy pilots searching for this plane had one on their dash as a back up.