PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - MoD looking at pulling Clyde frigate contract and giving it to the French
Old 18th Nov 2014, 22:36
  #37 (permalink)  
Not_a_boffin
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Portsmouth
Posts: 535
Received 178 Likes on 94 Posts
Oh yes. Project Brian. Madder than a box of frogs on acid. A "minimum change" T23 that just had a different hullform, a completely different propulsion system, no change to accommodation or safety standards and a bunch of weapons that had in no way been designed for the naval environment. Which was obviously going to cost "about the same" as a T23. What could possibly go wrong?

If you know anything about T45, you'll realise that it ain't a happy place right now - primarily for propulsion reasons. The old arguments against it as an ASW variant remain valid - you'd need to change most of the marine systems and you'd need to rearrange the internals, all of which make it a "new" ship in terms of drawings required and production effort. The only thing you might save on is some hydrodynamics tests, which tend to be comparatively cheap in any case. Certainly not a game changer in per ship cost.

T26 is eminently capable of being fixed. All it requires is the will to allow people to address the known problems (ie change the bits of the design that are causing the issues) and a hard-headed negotiation with BAES and HMT to get where the ship cost ought to be. That means being open and honest (internally) about what's wrong and ending the game of chicken.
Not_a_boffin is online now