PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AAIB Report A109E accident at Vauxhall, and Inquest Verdict
Old 10th Sep 2014, 21:25
  #38 (permalink)  
Flying Lawyer
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: London
Posts: 2,916
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
CAAAD
I am a bit surprised that in a high workload environment such as seems to have been the case, single pilot, poor visibility, and so on, the pilot was texting.
The texts sent/received in flight were whilst the pilot was in VMC above the cloud:

0747 Pilot to Witness A: VFR on top at 1500 feet
0748 Witness A to Pilot: But can you land?
0751 Pilot to Witness A: No hole hdg back to red
0753 Witness A to Pilot: Ok
0753 Pilot to Client: Over Elstree no holes I’m afraid hdg back to Redhill least we tried chat in 10

(The pilot obtained clearance to Redhill and, at 0753, ATC asked: “Rocket 2 do you have VMC or would you like an IFR transit?”
The pilot replied: “I have good VMC on top here, that’s fine, Rocket 2”.)

0755 Client to Pilot: Battersea is open
0755 Pilot to Operator: Can’t get in Elstree hdg back assume clear still
0755 Operator to Pilot: Yes it’s fine still here. (This text was not read.)

The last read and sent text messages were approximately four minutes before the collision with the crane:

At 0756, following the message from the client telling him Battersea was open, the pilot asked ATC to confirm.
It was only after ATC confirmed that it was, that he subsequently descended - while waiting to be cleared to Battersea.

He was using the radio to talk to ATC until a few seconds before impact.
The AAIB considered it unlikely that he was distracted at the same time by composing a text message.

I agree, and would go further: I regard it as extremely unlikely.
Firstly because there is not a shred of evidence that he was and, secondly, because the available evidence suggests that he wasn't.


FL

Last edited by Flying Lawyer; 10th Sep 2014 at 21:45.
Flying Lawyer is offline