Which brings me back to where this thread started.
I asked a SNP MSP (on the street) about pensions and taxation if I worked in England and lived in Scotland. Also, would I be able to access my Scottish GP if my taxes went to Westminster. Also about double taxation (which I had to explain to her). The only answer I got was that it would be decided after the referendum. She was either totally ignorant of the manifesto or she merely wanted to carry on playing the populist 'Braveheart' approach to her campaigning.