The expectation is one precision and one non precision
I thought the expectation was two different pilot interpreted approaches? Not arguing your point, I could well be wrong but that's how I always understood it.
If I may act as 'Referee' here, neither of you are quite right. The requirement is that the Test must include a 'published pilot interpreted approach/missed approach procedure', and during training, the Candidate must have been signed off as proficient on at least one other, 'different' type of approach, which may, or may not be 'pilot interpreted'. There is no requirement for either to be 'precision', or 'non-precision'.
MJ