One airplane that looks right to me, but I have never flown is the Ryan STA.
I don't know if I can say the PA25 looks right. But I have more hours in them than any other single type. They fly right, especially when unburdened by a glider.
I have flown a few different gliders, and owned an L33 Solo and a 1-35C. The humble 1-26 makes up in handling qualities what it lacks in performance.
My favorite is the Pitts. What a delightful machine to fly. Horrible for sightseeing though. But, we have J3's for that.
Bryan