PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Boeing Giving Up On Airliners?
View Single Post
Old 2nd May 2003, 18:25
  #54 (permalink)  
brabazon
 
Join Date: Jan 2000
Posts: 677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
OK here's what the UK's Department of Trade and Industry


http://www.dti.gov.uk/aerospace/launch-investment.htm

says about the A380 "launch investment" - ie it's not "given" to them without any return as is implied in Wino's posts. Also some interesting UK govt views on other countries' "aid" programmes.


LAUNCH INVESTMENT

Launch Investment is a risk-sharing Government investment in the design and development of specific civil aerospace projects in the UK. It has been used to support developments of airframes (or parts of airframes, such as wings), helicopters and aero engines. The investment is not a grant and is repayable to the Government at a real rate of return, usually via levies on sales of the product developed. By this means, the Government shares in the risk of the project, since the company may not achieve sales at the level or price forecast. Launch investment is available only to the aerospace sector and stems from the provisions of the Civil Aviation Act 1982.

Significant projects supported in the past include the Airbus A320 and A330/340 programmes. The A320 investment has already been repaid to the Government, and continues to provide a return. The A330/340 is contributing a steady stream of funds to the Exchequer, and is expected to pay for itself in the medium term. In November 1997, the Government reached agreement with Rolls-Royce to invest in new engines in the Trent family. This included the Trent 500 for the new Airbus A340-500/600 project, and also upgraded Trent 800 engines for the Boeing 777 family.

On 13 March 2000 the Government announced a new launch investment partnership with BAE SYSTEMS (Airbus UK) to support their participation in the Airbus A3XX ‘super-jumbo’ (subsequently launched as the A380). BAE SYSTEMS is now a 20% shareholder in the Airbus Integrated Company (AIC) with the European Aeronautic, Defence and Space Company (EADS), holding the remaining 80%. Airbus UK, the Centre of Excellence for wing design and manufacture, became a subsidiary company to the AIC and will receive the Launch Investment. This is the largest launch investment announced to date. More recently, the Government has also announced that it has joined with Rolls-Royce in an investment to develop the Trent 900 for the A380 and also the Trent 600 for future Boeing projects.

Launch investment enables the company and the Government to share the typically very high level of risk in aerospace projects, characterised by high costs, long payback periods, and a dearth of private sector investors. Launch Investment also recognises that modern aerospace projects are highly internationally mobile, and it enables the Government to capture valuable projects for the UK that might otherwise be carried out abroad.

The provision of launch investment is entirely discretionary. There is no formal scheme, promotion or budget for launch investment. Each launch investment application is considered on its merits against a range of established criteria and also, by the Treasury, against public expenditure constraints.

An applicant must demonstrate: that the project is technically and commercially viable; that Government investment is essential for the project to proceed on the scale and in the time-scale specified in the application; and that Government will recoup the investment at a real rate of return.

The Government undertakes a detailed assessment of the company’s business case and its claim that the project cannot be funded by alternative means. In addition, the Government assesses the technical viability of the project and the market for the product. Finally, an assessment is made of the wider benefits of the project to the economy beyond the company itself. These can include the spin-off of new technologies or production methods with wider applications in other sectors, or transferable improvements to the skill base. If it is decided to support an application, the Government will provide the minimum support required for the project to go ahead.

In view of the significant amounts of public expenditure involved, DTI closely monitors the progress of a supported programme. Payments are linked to actual expenditure by the company and to the achievement of specific technical milestones. Information is also required from the company on the development programme, the commercial position of the project and the financial position of the company.

Most Western countries with aerospace industries have some form of launch investment (including France, Germany, Spain, Netherlands and Italy). The US supports its industry by indirect measures, in particular the very large R&D programmes run by NASA and the Department of Defense. A range of international agreements exists to regulate financial support given to industry by Governments, and these apply equally to launch investment. Any offer of launch investment must therefore be consistent with the UK’s international obligations.

Principally, these are the European Union’s State Aid rules and the EC/US Agreement on support for large civil aircraft. This Agreement, signed in July 1992, covers all Airbus aircraft and aircraft with a capacity of 100 or more seats manufactured in the US. The Agreement recognises the two main types of support as direct support (such as launch investment), and indirect support (such as the R&D programmes run in the US). The main provisions are:

direct Government support limited to 33% of total development cost of a project;


direct support to be repaid to the Government within 17 years at a rate of return at least marginally above the cost of Government borrowing;


Indirect support limited to 3% of the civil aircraft industry’s annual commercial turnover;


detailed transparency requirements on both direct and indirect supports.
brabazon is offline