So 411A, which is it. Either the AA pilots are way overpaid and should have taken the concessions...
or....
They are really stupid for going with the pay concessions to keep them out of Chapter 11. Which is it? It seems you have argued both sides.
It appears that no matter what the outcome you have something bad to say. It is starting to appear more and more like sour grapes about a group that you were never quite able to join.