This entire thread is a bit like asking whether you prefer the colour orange, or the colour pink.
They both have their good points, and you can say rude things about both of them too.
For flight into a rough strip on a routine basis, your money would probably be on the Cessna. For easy flying in busy airspace with the need for good all round visibility, your money might be on the PA28.
There are better aircraft around than either of them, and for less money too. But I guess that would be a more interesting question.
