PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Asiana flight crash at San Francisco
View Single Post
Old 16th Jul 2013, 05:16
  #2189 (permalink)  
break_break
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Why would u care??
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Enough bullsh1t from general public and 100 hr private pilots
I have flown into KSFO numerous times with 21 years flying Boeing a/c, stated only to advise that this is not ill informed comment. Whilst the traveling public and pvt pilots are entitled to their opinion, this wild speculation does nothing to get to the crux of the accident.

1. The a/c was NOT given a slam dunk approach. Aligned on final at 4000 odd feet at 14 miles is not a slam dunk.
2. 230 kts at 14 miles is NOT a challenge.
3. Stabilised approach criteria was NON existant.
4. The a/c was on profile at 400 ft..... but with a ROD at close to double the stabilised equivalent, way outside the ballpark.
5. The 3 muppets up front said NOTHING. (I won't honour them with the term pilots)
6. A/T hold is a normal A/T sub mode. It only becomes a "trap" when you don't know what you are doing.
7. It is preferable that the guys up the pointy end know what they are *&$^ doing !
8. All ULH operations have a fatigue element. It is a professional's responsibility to mitigate that fatigue element by inflight rest, professional competence and knowing your game. The last two items were NON existent.

These morons masquerading as pilots deserve jail time, the charge professional incompetence.
Last edited by fire wall; 15th Jul 2013 at 14:39.
Usually it's more appropriate to wait for the outcome of NTSB's investigation, and thank goodness in this case it happened on US soil and we all can expect most probably a full transparent outcome.

However, in view of the blindly defensive Korean attitude after reading some of the most ridiculous and childish Korean news, nationally in Korea, or in US, or for that matter idiot coming on to Pprune in trying to convince the professional pilots' world of failure of automation or "bright light" at 500ft, they can all refer to probably the best written posting in this thread by Fire Wall.
break_break is offline