@cdogg
"If there really are a significant number of pilots who seriously think that Korean pilots as Koreans were more likely to make the errors it appears these pilots made, that's profoundly disappointing."
Why would you sign up just to make that comment? It adds nothing to the discussion and is pure political correctness. You have no idea what the cockpit culture and hand flying skills are like at Asiana. I don't either so I listen to the professionals who appear to be divided in their opinion.
To draw a stark contrast, your profession actively conceals individual performance data so the punters can't make an informed decision and Dr. Hodad can keep his job. If these Korean pilots were surgeons they'd be back in the operating theater tomorrow.