The "F-35 rules" scenario outlined by the Ozzies has been discussed.
Good news: It's feasible.
However, given the numbers it has to be heavily dependent on first-look/shot/kill for the F-35. I have seen this kind of scenario presented in F-22 sims.
This leads to an observation and a question.
First, the scenario is dependent on educated guesswork and analysis, just like the sims that Osley and the rest are trying to debunk.
Second, if the F-35 is that good why does the USAF think it needs the F-22?
Hate to waste time on recap, but we have been over this.