PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - The Regulatory Reform Program will drift along forever
Old 29th May 2013, 03:36
  #299 (permalink)  
Up-into-the-air
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: More than 300km from SY, Australia
Posts: 817
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
casa and it's failure to interface with industry

casa appears to have had the link removed and there is no way to "Like" or "Unlike", but here is a download of the transcript from yootube:

john mccormick says:

The regulations have to reflect reality,

0:09 they have to reflect where the industry is,

0:11 and at the moment they don't do that.

0:13 Because as I've said, they've grown up basically organically.

0:17 When there's been a regulation required, it's been written.

0:19And people have done the right thing as far as they knew,

0:22 interacting with the industry and meeting the requirements.

0:25 Nowadays, we need to get all that internationally aligned.

0:30So we need to follow ICAO.

0:32 Our regulations up to now basically haven't.

0:34 The CASA parts will align us with ICAO,

0:37 will align us with interoperability

0:39 with other countries around the world.

0:41 It puts us into a modern system.

0:43 Whereas our system at the moment,

0:45 we've relied heavily on exemptions and permissions.

0:47 There's in excess of 1,700 of those documents out there.

0:51 And that becomes a case of ruling almost by exemption,

0:55 which is not the best manner.

0:57 Because if you have a regulation, then you exempt somebody,

0:59 and you exempt somebody, and exempt somebody,

1:01 by the time you get out over here somewhere,

1:03 this original rule is a nonsense.

1:05 So updating it to where we are and reflecting the industry,

1:10 putting us in a better position for the 21st century,

1:13 making them simpler because everything is contained in one place.

1:18 In other words, the manuals of standards

1:20 contain all the standards now.

1:21You don't have to look through various publications,

1:23 as it is a little bit the technique required today.

1:26 So that's the important part of it.

1:28 Updating them to the 21st century,

1:30 allowing industry to move forward in the new regime of equipment

1:33 in avionics and things that we have available,

1:35 making sure we're internationally aligned

1:37 as best we can for interoperability,

1:39 and certainly harmonise with ICAO requirements.

1:42 However, the real issue is

1:44 what is the industry's ability to absorb change?

1:47 So the time we take to implement the regulations

1:50 will be driven basically

1:52 by how well we see the industry adapting to the changes.

1:55 Some of the changes are quite minor.

1:57 Some of them radically change the way people approach things.

2:00 But in each case, we're trying to enable industry to move forward

2:04 on a solid basis of knowing what the requirements are.

2:06 And those requirements, we are trying to make them

2:09 no more onerous than any other country that we would consider to be

2:12 someone we would benchmark ourselves against.

2:14 Reg reform is not a two-minute job,

2:17 and those people in the industry who say

2:19 "Oh, yeah, you just write this and away you go,"

2:21 it shows most probably the fact that they don't understand

2:24 the concepts or the principles involved at sufficient depth.

2:27 We're not trying to...

2:29 You know, we're dealing with what will go through parliament,

2:31 and become a CASA part, it will become law.

2:35 We can't just willy-nilly sign something over

2:39 because we think that's good on that day,

2:41 and yet some of our critics would want just that.

2:45 The process has to involve industry and the aviation community at large,

2:49 which of course is the travelling public as well.

2:51 We have the Notice of Proposed Rule Making process

2:53 involving the Standards Consultative Committee.

2:55 Then we have more public feedback.

2:57 Then we have the Notice of Final Rule Making.

3:00 And again there's feedback on that.

3:02 And then they go forward to parliament

3:03 and then to the Governor-General for the assent.

3:06 Industry, anybody, is free to comment at any stage during that process,

3:12 until we get to the Notice of Final Rule Making,

3:14 and we've decided and we've finished the rules,

3:15 then the rules are finished.

3:18 But it's a very lengthy period of time

3:20 available for people to make comments and I would encourage them to do so.

3:24 The ops regulations, as well, are inextricably interwoven

3:27 with the maintenance regulations

3:29 in that the maintenance regulations

3:30 call up for a certain amount of maintenance.

3:32 Now this is just our preferred option.

3:34 Again, it's open for consultation, so we haven't set anything in stone.

3:37 But if we look at what we have out there now

3:40 in the phase one of the maintenance regulations,

3:42 it says if you are this sort of operator,

3:45 if you are a part 121 operator, you'll need this type of maintenance.

3:48 If you're a 135 operator, you'll need this type of maintenance.

3:51 Well, straightaway, we can see that if Regulation 135 doesn't exist,

3:56 how do you know if you're a 135 operator or not?

3:59 So we can't, in a lot of ways,

4:00 just put the maintenance regulations out there

4:02 where they refer to operational regulation parts

4:07 without the operational parts also being available.

4:09 I consider that it will take us in excess of three years, possibly four,

4:13 to roll out the maintenance regulations in total.

4:16 That doesn't mean that we are slow or we're slack or anything like that.

4:21 What it means is that's about the rate

4:23 that we will see the industry take it up

4:24 because we don't want people to stop their day-to-day business...

4:29 ..having to suddenly adapt to a new set of regulations,

4:31 we want to transition them.

4:33 Part 141, for instance, on the flying training schools

4:35 is a whole new approach to demystifying

4:38 and decomplicating flying instruction for the simple operation,

4:42 the one-man, one-woman band,

4:44 or the small school that's not doing integrated training.

4:46 That's a whole new way of regulating that sector.

4:49 And we've gotta make sure that people can continue their business

4:52 but still, at the same time,

4:53 go through that transition period and come out the other side

4:56 in whatever reg part is applicable to them.

5:00 So that will take, I think,

5:02 a considerable amount of time in the coming years

5:05 purely because we'll have to drip-feed the industry.

5:08 And we have the fatigue rules around flight crew and cabin crew,

5:12 and then looking to develop

5:13 the fatigue rules for air traffic controllers.

5:16 again, the transition period for those will have to recognise the fact

5:19 that in some cases there may be crewing response changes,

5:24 there may be changes in roster patterns for the airlines, et cetera.

5:28 There may be some who wish to go to a fatigue risk management system.

5:31 There may be some who do not,

5:33 who wish to remain with the prescriptive regulations.

5:35 Hence, that transition period will be most probably three years

5:39 so that we can allow people time

5:41 to change rosters, recruit pilots, recruit cabin crew,

5:45 or reorganise, whatever they have to do to do their business.

5:49 We must make sure that we can facilitate that and allow them time.

5:52 So in reality, if we take three years,

5:55 I think it's a better result than if we pushed it through and said,

5:59 "By this day, you must be compliant."

6:01 We'd get a result. We'd be able to say, "Yep, everybody's compliant.

6:03 "Don't worry about that."

6:05 But it would be hollow.

6:06 I think one of the first goals I gave this organisation was

6:10 that we would have our staff properly trained and deployed.

6:13 Now we have to also train some of the industry.

6:16 There's also an onus on the industry to train themselves.

6:19 We provide the equipment, we provide the information,

6:21 we provide the background, we provide the regulations,

6:24 now it's up to you to assimilate all that into your organisation.

6:27 But training, education, the cornerstones of what we do.

6:32 If we do not educate people,

6:34 it doesn't matter what sort of regulation we write.

6:36 If you have the uneducated person,

6:38 they will do something most probably inadvertently,

6:42 which the regulation is not only there to make it some sort of offence

6:46 or to prohibit some action,

6:48 it is there because there is a safety requirement behind the regulation.

6:52 If people disregard the regulation out of ignorance,

6:56 well, that's something that we should hopefully be able to address

6:59 by helping them, but we can't make people learn.

7:02 We can't make people obey regulations.

7:04 The regulation doesn't make people safe.

7:06 It's their attitudes, their behaviours, their actions,

7:09 that's what makes them safe or unsafe.

7:11 But every publicly listed company that's an airline

7:15 or an air operator of some description in that business

7:17 that returns a profit at some stage in their process during the year,

7:24 they're deciding how much they're going to spend on safety.

7:26 If they spent everything they could on safety -

7:29 like continually renewing equipment, training people endlessly,

7:32 massive numbers of staff over and above what's required,

7:35 then they wouldn't show a profit.

7:39 So if they do show a profit, somebody, somewhere,

7:42 is making the decision of how much they're going to spend.

7:44 Our job is to make sure that the amount that is spent -

7:47 and I'm not interested in the dollar number, I'm interested in the result,

7:50 the result is showing that the safety is keeping

7:53 where the Australian public demands it is.

7:55 And after all, if we are writing the regulations,

7:57 then we answer to the parliament, and we answer to the industry, et cetera,

8:01 but in the end we answer to the Australian people.

8:03And it's the Australian public who demand a safe system.
Try that almost 25 years wasn't it??? and about 300million dollars???
Up-into-the-air is offline