Hm...ten threads on AF447 in Tech Log, every question asked and point made known to man covered ad infinitum by known experts and punters alike and this is still being argued with the self-same questions and points?
If all this is about researching, learning and understanding what really happened in this tragic accident, there are ten threads, plus an excellent
search tool created by one of the known experts who has contributed greatly to these threads from the beginning. At the beginning of each of the threads
here, there is placed by John Tullamarine a thorough summary with links to all threads, to various documents including the 4 BEA Reports and to other bits of value).
Rather than reiterate, re-argue or regurgitate old work and old theory that has been thoroughly discussed, may I respectfully suggest that this treasure-trove of discussions be reviewed which may then trigger new insights and imaginative theories which in turn may truly shed real light on why this accident occurred and why it continues to haunt and otherwise re-inform our imaginations.
These guys didn't set out to have an accident so what explains this in a way that helps others come to terms with the very real, and tragic aspect of the human factors involved? What is the pattern that connects?