TC, I hear what you say and agree with what you say. I just believe that the CVR points to this guy trying to do exactly what you say.
I agree. The crew made a human error on the day, despite their best efforts. No need to try and rubbish the whole outfit.
Easy for folks to criticise others and take a "holier than thou" attitude when they no longer fly themselves and are therefore no longer in danger of making a human error.