I tried to read this but gave up after a few pages...
To say it is a wee bit basis is an under statement, plus there are a few errors to say the least in his arguements.
He appears to igore the design faults in the new carriers, which have not included a basic design requirement for cat/trap operations to allow other aircraft types to operate from the deck, but I suspect he will blame the RAF or someone who is not from RN service.
I will get my coat... before we open up that can of worms.
Happy landing