Ok Hummingfrog, given that I am already in the No camp, convince me why I am right to be there from the UK perspective. In other words, explain to me what benefit the rest of the UK gets from Scotland's presence in the Union.
The politicians talk vaguely of "stronger together" and the leaflet posted through the door today spoke of "we help each other out". What is the tangible effect of these claims - why have successive UK governments all sought to retain Scotland in the Union if the country is such an economic drag.
Please no banter, visual, overt or otherwise latent - it is not translating
