@ Sloppy Joe
very nice long list of P2F accidents, thank you for taking the time to do that.
I can only talk speak from airlines that I have worked for and the standard is very high, if the TRE at Lion/Adam air is just letting pilots go on line willy nilly then of course this is a bad idea.
on the flip side of the coin you could argue that there have been a few experinced pilots whom have made just as bad mistakes, look at AF447