Macker-1ie
You say you are 25 years of age & yet berating a Senior & very experienced aviator that has worked in many parts of the world.
Try to "think" about what he is saying & not just literally interpret what has been written? Your type of response is exactly what he is talking about.
As you are so wise-could you describe a "bad landing"? What might seem like a bad landing could be a perfect landing-depending on the circumstances? On the other hand you could have what you consider a great landing from an "incompetent" crew that may have gone close to losing the aircraft several times during the flight but "fluked" a soft touchdown.